id say get the shovel if you like to tinker like me!! but i love the evo too cause its more reliable than the shovel. im going to get a shovel as my next bike !
Of course there are a lot of variables, but using only your limited supplied information, I'd say the 80 in. FXR is probably the best deal. Having said that, personally, I am partial to the 74 in. FLH (see sig pic). I'd try to get them to come down a little on the FLH. None of what I've said means anything if the engines, tranny, electrics, etc. are shot or need rebuilt. You'll just have to check them out before you buy. Hope this helps.