I have a 2000 XL1200 that i want to change the front pulley from a 29 tooth 1 1/8" width to a 32 tooth 1 1/8"width. Reason for the change is to drop my cruising RPM's on the highway at 75-80 mph. I know they changed the spine configuration around 2006 ish.
What stock 32 tooth 1 1/8" front pully should i use HD #?

I see a bunch on ebay i can get but not sure if they would fit. I dont believe a 1.5" front pully will work since it would be a bit wider than the stock 1 1/8" pulley or are they all the same width no matter the belt width is on the bike?

Or should i not be a cheap SOB and just buy it new and suck it up butter cup. The $ difference is ebay i can get them for $40ish used and a new one will run 150 to 175.

Thank you in advance