Had Elite 3's on my softail. Worst tire ever in the rain. Run the American Elites on my Ultra Limited and love them. No traction issues, no cupping issues and I get a consistent 20K per set despite aggressive riding. I get them from jakewilson.com for $315 per set, out the door and shipped.
If you are running a 200 tire the mileage will be lower than the narrower tires... so you have to know what the tire width is along with the achieved mileage to know what you are looking at.