Signs of lean running??
#11
I have a 2011 RGU and dealer told me no remap needed with just slip ons. I ran that way for a while and no issues. I put a SE air cleaner on and two different dealers told me no issues. One person on the inside said that stock ecm will get very close with this set up, not give you 100% maximum performance but very close and close enogh not to do any harm. closed loop is at around 14.3-14.4 and open loop is ~12.8 (WOT) etc. Plugs look good and never had a single ping. 3000 miles so far. I am going to do a SEPST but for now exremely happy with how it runs.
#12
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Detroit, the asshole of America
Posts: 1,268
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
7 Posts
That's what I was expecting to hear, honestly. I doubt an air cleaner and a set of slipon exhausts will put the factory ECU out of it's range of correction authority. Did your "in the inside" guy work for Harley? I'd guess all you'll really lose is some tip-in performance and won't have the extended rev limiter.
#13
We have developed a simple test for determining whether a stock HD is running lean:
1. Turn ignition switch on (be sure fob is within five fee of bike if security system present)
2. Turn kill switch to "Run" position; wait until engine light goes off
3. Press "Start" button
4. If motor starts and exhaust makes noise, engine is running lean
Just kidding (but not really). All HD's run lean from the factory and performance can be enhanced with an aftermarket fuel controller.
1. Turn ignition switch on (be sure fob is within five fee of bike if security system present)
2. Turn kill switch to "Run" position; wait until engine light goes off
3. Press "Start" button
4. If motor starts and exhaust makes noise, engine is running lean
Just kidding (but not really). All HD's run lean from the factory and performance can be enhanced with an aftermarket fuel controller.
#14
#15
The voltage the ECM is expecting from the O2 sensors are static without a device to change them i.e. XIEDs/SEPST, etc.
The calculation of A/F is based on the VE tables and voltage from the O2 sensors in the ECM. When you change the air cleaner you are changing the VE, and adjustments need to be made so that your computer can actually get to 14.x:1.
Just because your computer's A/F tables are set to closed loop doesn't mean it is going to make it run at the projected mixture. Like I said there are several variables that have to match up, and if you add air and remove more exhaust then you are going to run leaner than you think, and that is not good. You need away to see what your motor is doing, and adjust the engine for efficiency and for reliability. You cannot rely on a closed system to work for you when you change a component of that system. Doesn't work that way.
This is very vague, and I am still learning, but I don't think I am very far off. I cannot scientifically tell you the exact science, but you should be able to understand what I am saying.
The calculation of A/F is based on the VE tables and voltage from the O2 sensors in the ECM. When you change the air cleaner you are changing the VE, and adjustments need to be made so that your computer can actually get to 14.x:1.
Just because your computer's A/F tables are set to closed loop doesn't mean it is going to make it run at the projected mixture. Like I said there are several variables that have to match up, and if you add air and remove more exhaust then you are going to run leaner than you think, and that is not good. You need away to see what your motor is doing, and adjust the engine for efficiency and for reliability. You cannot rely on a closed system to work for you when you change a component of that system. Doesn't work that way.
This is very vague, and I am still learning, but I don't think I am very far off. I cannot scientifically tell you the exact science, but you should be able to understand what I am saying.
#16
#17
Tuner !
If you want one , put it on there . but it will run just fine without it ! And no risk in hurting your motor ! I have a 2010 streetglide with dresser duals , 4 " rineharts and se heavy breather ! And noe fuel management ! The auto-tune gets very close to where it should be . I DO NOT HAVE ANY KIND OF POPING GIRGLING ECT ! I live in houston ,Tx and I have seen 230 degrees once sitting in traffic , even the parade mode did not kick in ! I have also check my plugs , by choppin the throttle . PLUGS LOOK THE SAME WAY THEY WERE WHEN I BOUGHT IT NEW . . . . . .
#18
#19
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: The Internet (& Dyer, Indiana)
Posts: 7,580
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
If you want one , put it on there . but it will run just fine without it ! And no risk in hurting your motor ! I have a 2010 streetglide with dresser duals , 4 " rineharts and se heavy breather ! And noe fuel management ! The auto-tune gets very close to where it should be . I DO NOT HAVE ANY KIND OF POPING GIRGLING ECT ! I live in houston ,Tx and I have seen 230 degrees once sitting in traffic , even the parade mode did not kick in ! I have also check my plugs , by choppin the throttle . PLUGS LOOK THE SAME WAY THEY WERE WHEN I BOUGHT IT NEW . . . . . .
It runs lean to start with, and (you and) he made it even leaner.
There is large risk! If you think there ain't, then take the risk.
But don't advise others to do foolish stuff.
BTW: Plug reading ain't gonna tell you a lot on these newer injected bikes, unless they are way rich. That you ain't gonna see until you start adding fuel.
.
Last edited by Faast Ed; 10-17-2010 at 05:04 PM.