There are some scratches from being in storage but I think most if not all can be buffed out. I have these listed for a buddy of mine who is in the middle of a rear fender/extended bag project and he may just have these sprayed at the same time. Or I will pass along any offers for them in their current condition.
Since you provided the part number 58854-09CYS, I can assume these are in fact OEM from Harley Davidson? I've read that some 3rd-party aftermarket dealers also stamp their products.
These are stock OEM Harley fairing lowers that came on a 2009 Ultra Classic. They are not perfect (see pics) but they are OEM Harley...PM me an offer if interested.