How much of that style do you want?

KBB says a 2009 Nightster, from a dealer, $,5875, now that means like showroom condition. NADA says Average Retail $5,555 again that's average for a nice looking bike at a dealership. I don't think a dealership would touch that with a 10' pole.

If I wanted that style bike and would make some of those modifications anyway I'm thinking somewhere around $2,500-$3,000 But my Sportsters don't look anything like that. If I was looking for another project and had $1,500 laying around I might offer him that. Agree with others who say it has been rode hard and put up wet. If you buy it expect to do some work on it.