I don't belong to AARP and still got an excellent price out of Foremost. I checked Geico but they were as expensive as Progressive. I have an excellent credit history and driving history, so I have no idea why Geico would have been so expensive. Sometimes I wonder what these companies really use to determine their premiums. BTW, I'm ex military and have USAA insurance for everything else. Too bad they don't cover bikes anymore.
Taterdog - when did you check with USAA about not covering bikes. I have a full coverage policy with them on my motorcycle that I renew every 6 months as you would well know. I would double check on that no motorcycle coverage with another agent. You can't beat USAA for prices