They all work about the same but the HD ones are the least obtrusive and the best looking.

 

I just installed a pair of RJ's Originals and they look great! Got them used from another HDForum member for $100 shipped. Can't wait to take it for a ride to see/feel the difference. Very easy install too.

 

I installed the Captain Itch crotch cooler on my 2011 Electra Glide and it made a huge difference! Installation was as easy as R&R the seat. No bolts, nuts, zip ties, or loctite. I put 625 miles on over the weekend with one whole day in shorts. Can't believe it was that simple to eliminate the hot spot. It is truly the best comfort ad-on that I've ever used. Made in America!

 

OK, what's the deal w/spending a tad more for quality...you've got a $21K bike w/~$2K added parts and complaining about spending additional $70 on heat shields (i.e. RJS)...?? Not knocking the Doc, but BS on being "miserly."

 

I bought the Harley ones and had them color match painted. They certainly help a lot and I like the look. However, I have heard that the Capt. Itch product really does the job of cutting down the heat, and you can't beat dealing with the Capt! Good folks!

 

I chose the RJS product over the Capt.'s but it was just a matter of looks,I thought they would look better on my bike and they deliver what's promised.Both excellent products in my opinion.

 

I have the Kuryakyn and they look great and seem to help with the heat. If they ever break or crack I will go with Capt Itch as I can see how the coverage is better.

 

just got my heat shields Nice was a trick getting them on 5 mins. tops good deal in socal they work great THANKS!!!

 

Agreed, the wife begged me to put an HD one on her FXDC before we took last weeks rode trip and she claims it made a huge diff....I believe those are made very well. I have not been shy about my concerns with these devices but it was her bike and she didn't want her thighs blistered. Me, I did a tank lift on my RK, it solved any heat issues and opened up the rear jug to get lots of air across it which to me is a solution not a bandaid.

 

I have both Cap's and RJ's.
I like RJ's for looks the best.
Cap's are easier installed.
They look more like a saddle blanket and look the best on a softail IMO.

The right side of bike is still hot, so went with Rinehart slim-line duals.
This should help with the heat dispersion, at least this is what they are purported to do.
I should have them in 2 weeks. New product only out 4-6 weeks.