I had the leather ones. They looked great but I hated that i couldnt lock them. They do make a lock kit but its expensive for what it is.. I switched over to the hard bags and havent looked back..
I had both and swapped out depending on where I was riding for a destination.
Did that for 14 years on my 2001 Road King Classic.
Pricey option but it was worth it to me.
Myron
I didn't like not being able to lock them but I also had marks on the tops from the docking hardware, which drove me crazy. The hard bags are crazy expensive from HD so I ordered from Surdyke HD and saved over $500. They look good, but now I wish I would have just gone ahead and bought the extended bags from one of the after market guys.