I have one, I like the shield. I would prefer it comes formed to the shape of the batwing (it comes flat as a board). It has a small hairline crack by the center screw (and no, I didn't over tighten it). It showed up after the winter, as long as it doesn't get worse I'll stay with it. Overall I'm happy with it and it looks way better then stock.
I put a dark smoked 8" on my street glide the week I bought my bike. Ordered it over the phone and it arrived two days later. No problems with the transaction or the install. Had the same shield on 3 years now. I'd buy another one and probably will.