M8 crank breathers are crap
#11
When I first bought my bike oil carry over was no problem. Then the rings got seated and the weather got hot. Now, I am getting oil carry over on every ride. Have already thrown away the original air filter. After cleaning it a few times it was so oil soaked it was worthless. Lots of others are reporting issues. One member had his umbrella valves replaced and it made no difference. Harley better not have a problem, warrant wise, with people venting to atmosphere. Because we shouldn't be expected to buy new air filters every 3k miles.
#12
#13
Yes, don't want this crap going into your engine.
Getting it out increases performance, helps with cooling, and increases engine longevity.
LINK to external breather systems for Twin Cam and M8 engines.
Getting it out increases performance, helps with cooling, and increases engine longevity.
LINK to external breather systems for Twin Cam and M8 engines.
Last edited by RobertJO; 08-15-2018 at 02:36 PM.
#14
#15
So I have to ask a question here - Is this blow by noticeable without removing the air cleaner cover? I suppose I can answer my own question by taking the cover off and looking to see if its a problem (currently traveling on business), but was just curious to know if I'm not seeing it external to the cover, if I can stop worrying about it.
#16
The interesting part is its a problem that makes itself worse. When the air filter gets oil logged it becomes easier for the motor to suck air in through the breathers than it is to pull air through a dirty filter. In turn more crap gets sucked in. Easiest fix is a catch can. My evo actually does this sometimes even after I put new umbrella valves in.
I really think the sumping issue is a combination of things just like this. With a poor breather system it cant be good for crankcase pressure. It has to be a few things being off to cause the sump issue, it even explains why some bikes have it and some dont.
I really think the sumping issue is a combination of things just like this. With a poor breather system it cant be good for crankcase pressure. It has to be a few things being off to cause the sump issue, it even explains why some bikes have it and some dont.
The following users liked this post:
Candler (05-30-2019)
#17
2018 RGU 7300 miles.
I recently cleaned my filter, using the book method of soapy water. The filter was removed after 7k miles. There was a fair amount of oil soaked into the bottom of the filter, directly below the breather hose, but nothing I could detect above. There was a dollop of oil sitting right on the bottom of the intake throat of the throttle body.
I'm thinking this oil on the throttle body, as well as the filter area below it, is dripping out of the hose during times the bike is shut down overnight in the garage. Couldn't be more than a drop here and there, but builds up over time.
Nothing much gets out of the filter element. The inside of the air box is all but dry of oil. My engine oil consumption is what I consider normal, a rate of about a quart every 5k miles.
I recently cleaned my filter, using the book method of soapy water. The filter was removed after 7k miles. There was a fair amount of oil soaked into the bottom of the filter, directly below the breather hose, but nothing I could detect above. There was a dollop of oil sitting right on the bottom of the intake throat of the throttle body.
I'm thinking this oil on the throttle body, as well as the filter area below it, is dripping out of the hose during times the bike is shut down overnight in the garage. Couldn't be more than a drop here and there, but builds up over time.
Nothing much gets out of the filter element. The inside of the air box is all but dry of oil. My engine oil consumption is what I consider normal, a rate of about a quart every 5k miles.
#18
The interesting part is its a problem that makes itself worse. When the air filter gets oil logged it becomes easier for the motor to suck air in through the breathers than it is to pull air through a dirty filter. In turn more crap gets sucked in. Easiest fix is a catch can. My evo actually does this sometimes even after I put new umbrella valves in.
I really think the sumping issue is a combination of things just like this. With a poor breather system it cant be good for crankcase pressure. It has to be a few things being off to cause the sump issue, it even explains why some bikes have it and some dont.
I really think the sumping issue is a combination of things just like this. With a poor breather system it cant be good for crankcase pressure. It has to be a few things being off to cause the sump issue, it even explains why some bikes have it and some dont.
The following users liked this post:
eibo (08-27-2021)
#19
[QUOTE=Yamaharley;17597413]The interesting part is its a problem that makes itself worse. When the air filter gets oil logged it becomes easier for the motor to suck air in through the breathers than it is to pull air through a dirty filter. In turn more crap gets sucked in. Easiest fix is a catch can. My evo actually does this sometimes even after I put new umbrella valves
These are one way valves, you are going to have to explain how they can suck in.
These are one way valves, you are going to have to explain how they can suck in.
#20