Question on Softail vs Dyna
Road Master
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 774
Likes: 4
From: SC
RE: Question on Softail vs Dyna
A lot of good advice so far. Whether or not the Dyna is a better bike than the Softail, if you really want the Softail and get the Dyna because you just couldn't wait, you'll never be happy with the Dyna. Just stick it out and get the one you want.
Extreme HDF Member
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 10,045
Likes: 36
From: ST. Louis
RE: Question on Softail vs Dyna
Tell the dealer what you want, he'll dealer trade for the color you want.
If not then you're gonna have trouble later on with him.
Of course he's gonna push what he has on the floor.
That's easier for the salesman.
If not then you're gonna have trouble later on with him.
Of course he's gonna push what he has on the floor.
That's easier for the salesman.
Road Captain
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 503
Likes: 75
From:
RE: Question on Softail vs Dyna
Before I bought my Deluxe I test rode the Deluxe, Heritage, Custom, Street Bob and even the Street Glide. I dont know if it was just the bob I rode but it had a nasty vibration through the pegs, much, much worse then my Sportster had. The vibration at idle is cool, but int he end if you want to ride the "Cadilac" or Harleys wait for the Custom.
Road Master
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 770
Likes: 2
From: East NM
RE: Question on Softail vs Dyna
Ride both, buy what feels good to you. The feel of a Softail is very different from a Dyna. Here are a few of the differences;
1. Softail has more rear unsprung weight, so bumps will be slightly more harsh.
2. Dyna has rubber engine mounts. This makes the engine mounting more complex. Below around 2K RPM, the engine suspension bottoms out and the bike shakes like a Brit thumper. Above that, it smooths out, but you will still feel a bit of movement if your leg touches the airfilter. Some find this annoying, some don't.
3. Softail has a balance shaft for vibration control. The engine is bolted directly to the frame, making life simpler for the mechanic. This balance shaft takes a measurable amount of power to spin. So, if you absolutely HAVE to be first to the next redlight, get a Dyna.
So, just buy the one that feels best when you ride it. If you don't, it's likely to become a garage queen.
1. Softail has more rear unsprung weight, so bumps will be slightly more harsh.
2. Dyna has rubber engine mounts. This makes the engine mounting more complex. Below around 2K RPM, the engine suspension bottoms out and the bike shakes like a Brit thumper. Above that, it smooths out, but you will still feel a bit of movement if your leg touches the airfilter. Some find this annoying, some don't.
3. Softail has a balance shaft for vibration control. The engine is bolted directly to the frame, making life simpler for the mechanic. This balance shaft takes a measurable amount of power to spin. So, if you absolutely HAVE to be first to the next redlight, get a Dyna.
So, just buy the one that feels best when you ride it. If you don't, it's likely to become a garage queen.
Big Kahuna HDF Member
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 29,598
Likes: 19
From: Oregon
RE: Question on Softail vs Dyna
ORIGINAL: Oldtimer of NM
Ride both, buy what feels good to you. The feel of a Softail is very different from a Dyna. Here are a few of the differences;
1. Softail has more rear unsprung weight, so bumps will be slightly more harsh.
2. Dyna has rubber engine mounts. This makes the engine mounting more complex. Below around 2K RPM, the engine suspension bottoms out and the bike shakes like a Brit thumper. Above that, it smooths out, but you will still feel a bit of movement if your leg touches the airfilter. Some find this annoying, some don't.
3. Softail has a balance shaft for vibration control. The engine is bolted directly to the frame, making life simpler for the mechanic. This balance shaft takes a measurable amount of power to spin. So, if you absolutely HAVE to be first to the next redlight, get a Dyna.
So, just buy the one that feels best when you ride it. If you don't, it's likely to become a garage queen.
Ride both, buy what feels good to you. The feel of a Softail is very different from a Dyna. Here are a few of the differences;
1. Softail has more rear unsprung weight, so bumps will be slightly more harsh.
2. Dyna has rubber engine mounts. This makes the engine mounting more complex. Below around 2K RPM, the engine suspension bottoms out and the bike shakes like a Brit thumper. Above that, it smooths out, but you will still feel a bit of movement if your leg touches the airfilter. Some find this annoying, some don't.
3. Softail has a balance shaft for vibration control. The engine is bolted directly to the frame, making life simpler for the mechanic. This balance shaft takes a measurable amount of power to spin. So, if you absolutely HAVE to be first to the next redlight, get a Dyna.
So, just buy the one that feels best when you ride it. If you don't, it's likely to become a garage queen.
Road Warrior
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 1,338
Likes: 92
From:
RE: Question on Softail vs Dyna
You can't compromise on the bike you want when spending so much. Tell the dealer you are ready to buy a Softail Customas soon ashe can get one. If you don't get a call in a week, find another dealer that is not lazy and unmotivated.
RE: Question on Softail vs Dyna
And regarding local dealer loyalty, don't worry about it. They won't be loyal to you regarding preferential service.
Cruiser
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 123
Likes: 1
From:
RE: Question on Softail vs Dyna
It's not a Dyna vs Softail thing in my mind ... It's about you getting the bike you want. Ten years ago when you had to wait months for a big twin, you might need to compromise a bit more. But those days are gone. Tell the dealer what you want and make them get it for you. If that is asking too much, find another dealer.
Road Captain
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 565
Likes: 0
From: England
RE: Question on Softail vs Dyna
If the dealer isn't prepared to get you the model & colour you want, do not use that dealer. If they aren't prepared to offer any kind of service to get your deal, imagine how they'll behave once they have it!!
Tourer
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 496
Likes: 0
From: Keller , Texas
RE: Question on Softail vs Dyna
Waited 3 weeks for Mine. I would have waited 3 more. Get what you want or youll never feel right.Its the Same message they gave you in the Dyna forum on this exact same post.