Try this: if it was a 2012 Dyna seat it would fit all Dyna's from 06 and up

 

I have a 2012 super glide seat fitted to my 2014 street bob - totally different looking seat from the one you were sold. as others have said dyna seats are inter-changeable from 2006 onwards. you will be covered under ebay rules and shouldn't have too much problem in getting your cash back .

 

Hopefully he figured it out and hasn't been without a seat for the past 2 years!

 

See if it looks like this seat off A 2005 Super Glide Custom.

http://atlanta.craigslist.org/nat/mcy/4566168765.html

 

06 up Dyna bikes will interchange.
1999 or 2002 the seats are mostly model specif.
I am tying to find a fl sundowner or standard fl touring seat with the female mount/tongue in the front. for years 2012-13 for a street glide to put on my 05 super glide.

 

LOL- just noticed the date on the original post .perhaps the seat has grown in the last 2 years and now fits !

 

It is shorter in the pic than the stock Superglide seat than the one I have in the attic.