Ive put up a page showing some comparisions of the following seats on my 07 Street Glide. Hopefully, this will help those who may be considering purchasing one of these seats. You can get a sense of how they may sit compared to one another, as well as how they look on the bike.

Ultimate Seat
Mustang Solo with Rider pillion
Mustang touring seat (full size, not the sport tour)
HD Sundowner


http://home.comcast.net/~kceder/seats.html

 

ww1flyingace,

You are AWESOME! Thank you very much for doing this. IMHO, the Mustang seat looks the best with the Tour-Pak and Rear Speakers installed. It just seems to fill up that area the best. I just wish it had the Street Glide stitching. Can you tell me how thick the passenger cushion is for Sundowner and Mustang seats?

Frank

 

Which one feels the best under the butt.

 

For those curious, I kept the big Mustang.

I have had the Sundowner since I got the bike, and have about 5000 miles on it. The other seats, I rode for between 300-800 miles on, each. (not all in one ride)

1. The Ultimate COULD be a great seat (my wife vastly prefered it, out of the box, to all the others) but it needs more shaping and contouring in the rider section. The Memory foam is very good however. It shoves you furthest forward of them all. Also, it was only comfortable if I sat right in the "pocket" of the seat. If I moved around, scooted forward a bit etc, it was not as comfortable.

The Mustang Solo is good, but it sits so low because it has less padding. It was good for about 100 miles before I had to get off however. The low lip on the rear of the drivers section did bother me somewhat, even with the backrest on.

I personally really like the Sundowner, but the Wife cant ride on it for more than 30 miles. The passenger section is just too small and too hard. I SUSPECT that in time, with enough miles, the Foam in the Sundowner would break down and collapse more than any of the other seats. Its just not made as robustly as the others. So while its comfortable now, I suspect it may not be in 10k miles or so.

The big mustang is simply the cushiest of the bunch. Its padded the most/best, and it supports you the best. It does sit you up a good inch higher than the others, but its about the same as the stock touring seats (ElectraGlide) in position, in my opinion.


Having said that, I had the Mustang modified:

1. had the drivers section lowered .75" and moved back .5 (as far as we could go and still use the existing cover)
2. Had a .75" thick cross-mesh jell pad put into the passenger pillion (wifes butt is just too damn tender!)
3. Had the nose of the passenger section narrowed a bit and rounded off at the top edge.

I may still Add a half inch of memory foam overall.

My wife could only go 60 miles on the sundowner, and was in PAIN at the end. (not just a tired butt.... she was seriously hurting)

60-80 miles on either of the Mustangs, as they came out of the box.

She did 170 miles on the Ultimate (memory foam) with 1 break, but was a bit uncomfortable at the end.

She did 180 miles on the modified Mustang, (cross gel) with 1 break, and felt fine when we got home.

Having said that, she is 5' 4", about 140 pounds, and she just needs a really cushy seat to be happy. Moreso than anyone else I have ever known.

 

Thanks, I've bookmarked your link. It's a keeper.

 

Very nice review. i was wondering sundowner or 1 piece mustang which seat puts the passenger higher above the rider. i am also looking at tallboy and comfort stitch any comments would be appreciated. new seat will try to keep passenger happy thanks

 

WOW! Excellent job, thanks so much, this should be a sticky.

Im waiting on my sundowner now.


Great post.

sj

 

ww1flyingace,

Posts like yoursare what makes this forum great.

Thanks.

 

ww1flyingace,

Great post...I'm looking for a seat now and you just made my choice harder ! J/K

Thanks again.

 

Wow, thanks for the post. You have helped me make a decision. MustangFull Touring for me. I've been reviewing all the posts of those looking for THE seat to buy. After seeing your pics, I can now buy with confidence. Thanks.