Is this normal????
#1
05-23-2016, 03:25 PM
Is this normal????
I am on my third Harley, but this is the first one I bought new. At 2000 mile service I had a shifter shaft seal leak, today I took it in for 5000 mile service only to find out I have an oil seal leak and my primary was filling with oil. This must have started leaking today or yesterday because I replaced the derby cover two days ago and I did not notice excess oil. Mechanic said when he removed it today the primary immediately started spilling oil.
#2
05-23-2016, 03:33 PM
Ultimate HDF Member
#4
05-23-2016, 10:02 PM
Seasoned HDF Member
#5
05-24-2016, 11:24 AM
#6
05-24-2016, 12:20 PM
Club Member
#7
05-24-2016, 04:55 PM
Things can happen even to a newer bike.Seems funny though you had just had the clutch cover off and didn't have a problem with excess oil flowing out.If its under warranty, let them do their thing.Hope the tech was smart enough to have bike upright and not on the side stand.
" Hope the tech was smart enough to have bike upright and not on the side stand. "
And add to that the fact that when oil is up to full op temp it expands x-amount increasing it's lvl within the primary making it seem at though it may be overfilled when truly not.
HD's do have that issue once in a while but not that often esp at only 5k miles.
Even though it may still be under warranty its never good to have people wrenching on the bike if its not really needed because if poor workmanship is done they can end up with more problems then you 1st had if any at all.
If it was my bike still under warranty i'd drain & refill prim case as per manual and also check trans & motor oil to ensure they are @ proper lvl & the shop didnt mess with them.
Then i'd take the bike for a ride or 2 and then check prim case oil lvl again with bike/motor/prim case at same approx temp it was when he just changed prim case oil and that bike is upright/not on side the stand.
If it shows normal lvl close it up and check again 300-500 mile later,if still checks out ok on this 2nd oil lvl check you should be good to go and either the wrench @ the shop screwed up or the shop is trying to generate more warranty srv'c work.
But if the either the 1st or 2nd prim case oil lvl chk shows the oil lvl in prim case did in fact increase when propely cheking it with bike not on sidestand and at same approx temp too ,that's when i'd take it back to the shop for warranty srv'c.
Scott
Last edited by wscott; 05-24-2016 at 05:00 PM.
Trending Topics
#8
05-24-2016, 08:05 PM
Extreme HDF Member
Things can happen even to a newer bike.Seems funny though you had just had the clutch cover off and didn't have a problem with excess oil flowing out.If its under warranty, let them do their thing.Hope the tech was smart enough to have bike upright and not on the side stand.
#9
05-24-2016, 08:29 PM
Outstanding HDF Member
==================================
" Hope the tech was smart enough to have bike upright and not on the side stand. "
And add to that the fact that when oil is up to full op temp it expands x-amount increasing it's lvl within the primary making it seem at though it may be overfilled when truly not.
HD's do have that issue once in a while but not that often esp at only 5k miles.
Even though it may still be under warranty its never good to have people wrenching on the bike if its not really needed because if poor workmanship is done they can end up with more problems then you 1st had if any at all.
If it was my bike still under warranty i'd drain & refill prim case as per manual and also check trans & motor oil to ensure they are @ proper lvl & the shop didnt mess with them.
Then i'd take the bike for a ride or 2 and then check prim case oil lvl again with bike/motor/prim case at same approx temp it was when he just changed prim case oil and that bike is upright/not on side the stand.
If it shows normal lvl close it up and check again 300-500 mile later,if still checks out ok on this 2nd oil lvl check you should be good to go and either the wrench @ the shop screwed up or the shop is trying to generate more warranty srv'c work.
But if the either the 1st or 2nd prim case oil lvl chk shows the oil lvl in prim case did in fact increase when propely cheking it with bike not on sidestand and at same approx temp too ,that's when i'd take it back to the shop for warranty srv'c.
Scott
" Hope the tech was smart enough to have bike upright and not on the side stand. "
And add to that the fact that when oil is up to full op temp it expands x-amount increasing it's lvl within the primary making it seem at though it may be overfilled when truly not.
HD's do have that issue once in a while but not that often esp at only 5k miles.
Even though it may still be under warranty its never good to have people wrenching on the bike if its not really needed because if poor workmanship is done they can end up with more problems then you 1st had if any at all.
If it was my bike still under warranty i'd drain & refill prim case as per manual and also check trans & motor oil to ensure they are @ proper lvl & the shop didnt mess with them.
Then i'd take the bike for a ride or 2 and then check prim case oil lvl again with bike/motor/prim case at same approx temp it was when he just changed prim case oil and that bike is upright/not on side the stand.
If it shows normal lvl close it up and check again 300-500 mile later,if still checks out ok on this 2nd oil lvl check you should be good to go and either the wrench @ the shop screwed up or the shop is trying to generate more warranty srv'c work.
But if the either the 1st or 2nd prim case oil lvl chk shows the oil lvl in prim case did in fact increase when propely cheking it with bike not on sidestand and at same approx temp too ,that's when i'd take it back to the shop for warranty srv'c.
Scott
#10
05-24-2016, 09:04 PM
Ok so here is the deal, I let them do the repair and when leaving I said so my next service is at 10,000 right. TECH says no you have pre-paid service so the next one is at 7500. What gives I have been paying extra for full SYN and getting the oil changed every 2 to 3 thousand anyone else ever hear of this????