FLSS is FINALLY done, I think.....
type seat, but since the pogo-style only has like .5"-.75" of movement,
I would say no way is it "better" than a 2" - 3" set of barrell springs.
I agree with the other observation; if you're planning on going
500 miles in a day every day, you probably ought to start with
different platform. In my opinion, at the very least you'd need
some sort of air shock system like the Shotgun Shock or the SAS....
good luck,
T.
...snip....
What I would like to know about your seat setup is this:
1. How much higher are you sitting over the stock seat?
2. In your opinion, is the pogo style suspension better than the barrel spring for ride quality?
The reason I asked the first question is that I want to put a windshield on and I want to make sure I get wind coverage. I am plenty tall to deal with the increased ride height. I am expecting that it changed the handlebar position and center of gravity, too. Have you noticed any detriments from this?
The second question is based upon my wanting a bike that will cover 400-500 miles without too much of a beating on the operator. I am relatively spry, but you know...
PB
The seat itself is very comfortable due to the shape. In fact, I'm surprised bike designers ever went away from a contoured seating surface. If you look at the high end aftermarket seats for long range touring bikes (Bill Meyer for example), the concept still exists in a cushioned style seat. The pogo isn't a real pogo with a long spring though. Your suspension is almost solely controlled by your shocks. The Pogo gives a very slight amount of spring, and some minor flex in the seat pan. You would want to replace the shocks with non-lowered versions at the least.
HD makes "comfort" shocks for about $300 (just standard non-lowered Softail shocks.)
Progressive makes the 522 series that's said to be a good improvement over the standard Softail shocks ($400-600 depending on options.)
Several air ride systems are available, but they add complexity and opportunity for failures. If you bar hop or ride to local bike shows, the risk is minimal. If you're 1000 miles from home, you don't want a leaking suspension. I've not used them, so their reliability (and comfort value for that matter) is unknown to me. People swear by the Shotgun Shock, but I prefer first hand experience before spending $1500 on a "maybe."
From an adaptability standpoint, aftermarket luggage capacity options are few and expensive. I overcame this with a home made, modular, detachable luggage rack. The smaller piece shown here is good for a medium duffel or tail bag.

The secondary rack can handle two medium duffels (one on each side) and a large duffel on top.



The secondary rack bolts to PlusNuts in the smaller rack. The whole system is detachable with HD detachable hardware. It comes off in seconds and can be stored in a tent or hotel room to accommodate day rides at the destinations.
Ignore the old school bungees. I have ROK straps for this purpose.
You will also want the 21" windshield with lowers like Gunny's awesome setup. Or Wachuko uses the more modern HD wind splitter.
The S-Series cruise control is a great long-day feature, but compromises include lack of radio and GPS. I use a helmet mounted Uclear Bluetooth system and my phone for these features.
It will never be as comfortable or convenient as a Street Glide or my BMW R1200GS for example, but sometimes you want the ability to have your naked cruiser available at a destination 1000 miles from home. I wouldn't roll into Daytona or Thunder Beach on my BMW, but I could easily get there on the Slim S.
I'm not sure one could make a Slim into a 2-up long-range bike. Certainly not with a pogo seat.
Last edited by SLV; Dec 29, 2015 at 12:17 PM.
I am not scared of 500-600 mile days on lightweight bikes. I currently ride a 2004 Yamaha FZ1 that is a good ride, but fairly light. The wind tosses it around pretty easily. The wind protection is also lacking. It has served me well, but I wanted to get into this Softail Slim style.
I had always wanted to do a homage to a WLA with more current tech and features. I originally though about starting with a heritage springer, and then a crossbones (you can see the timeline that I have been hankering to do this) but now I see the best starting "canvas" in the FLS and the other S is just a bit extra fun for me.
Anyhow, I think all of your comments are right on the money. I thought about a road king classic but I don't like the way they feel. I have ridden street glides, ultras and electras - they just don't turn me on. Now the softails, particularly the more nimble with the bigger front wheel and still a narrow rear tire, still have that sporty feel (for me). Thats where I am coming from on that.
Now, I have planned on doing progressive suspension front and rear on this scoot. I don't want to scrape floorboards too much and I also want a predictable and tight ride. I realize that most of the suspension will come directly from that, and not the seat or mount therein, but I will take from where I can while keeping the function and form correct. Function has top priority, though. I like the pogo system for the fact that it seems like a much more rigid and precise mounting. The last thing I want is the seat moving around in the sweepers.
SLV, you hit the nail right on the head with the luggage system. I was already thinking on how to do that in a practical way that was relatively easy to dismount. I can't think of a more elegant design than what I saw in your pictures. I really want to pursue that. I need to hit you up for part numbers and the like. I carry a drybag for my kit that I had custom made at Bucks Bags in Boise, Idaho. It would set perfectly on the rear platform you designed. After that, I will look for some saddlebags.
I will definitely go for the 21" windshield and building up some lowers should be a feat I can manage - with some tips from this site, of course.
Now, if I can download the perfect design that is swimming around in my head and get it to become a reality (within reason) before my trip in July, I will be "shitting in high cotton"!
Thanks,
PB
I don't want to clutter Gunny's thread any more than I have, so jump over to here.
https://www.hdforums.com/forum/softa...home-base.html
I posted the same reply from above and I will add an additional post showing the luggage rack.
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders



