I got the nut and bolt replacement for the OEM cotter pin setup and tightened those ****'s down nice and hard and it fixed mine.

 

i got shims..still does it on one peg...will rebend them again.

 

Your new pegs should be the same width as your stock pegs since they are Harley Pegs. Take your Spring Steel Tension Spacers out and take a pair pliers, insert the ends of the spacers into jaws of pliers and bend slightly to give them more tension. If you try putting 2 spacers in they will not fit. If that doesn't work you can always buy new ones, they are the least expensive items that Harley sells. Good Luck.

 

My stock shims were in backwards, I bought 2 new ones for about $1

 

Thanks for all the responses, i gotta go to the dealer, i will grab a couple shims, thanks