Softail Vs Dyna
#21
12-03-2006, 04:03 AM
Outstanding HDF Member
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Between Chicago & Milwaukee
Posts: 3,043
Received 111 Likes
on
48 Posts
RE: Softail Vs Dyna
ORIGINAL: Six Pack
I've been looking at both, and based purely on looks, I don't have a clear favorite.
If you were looking at roughly the same price for both bikes (rigid frame looks not a factor), why would one pick a softtail over a dyna? I've been told the dyna has better handling and acceleration, but the softail is more versatile.
Has anyone ever owned or ridden both? I'll be trading in my sporty, so I have grown accustom to great handling. Is the softail a little more comfortable on the highways for longer rides?
EDIT - I'm just looking for a general idea on Dyna and Softails - not any specific type.
I've been looking at both, and based purely on looks, I don't have a clear favorite.
If you were looking at roughly the same price for both bikes (rigid frame looks not a factor), why would one pick a softtail over a dyna? I've been told the dyna has better handling and acceleration, but the softail is more versatile.
Has anyone ever owned or ridden both? I'll be trading in my sporty, so I have grown accustom to great handling. Is the softail a little more comfortable on the highways for longer rides?
EDIT - I'm just looking for a general idea on Dyna and Softails - not any specific type.
Why do you want to trade in your Sportster ? Maybe thats the secret to knowing which bike to replace it with.
#22
12-03-2006, 06:13 AM
RE: Softail Vs Dyna
i own a 2005 fatboy ann.and i also bought me a 2006 fxd,both in brilliant silver.my fatboy is more of a cruiser and is very comfortable at long rides.my dyna is more verstile
and has a six speed trans,which kicks in at 60 mph.which also is good at long runs.both are good on oil.i use syn.3i also have power commanders and v&h big shot stags.
i have no complaints with my bikes.good luck
and has a six speed trans,which kicks in at 60 mph.which also is good at long runs.both are good on oil.i use syn.3i also have power commanders and v&h big shot stags.
i have no complaints with my bikes.good luck
#23
12-03-2006, 10:05 AM
Road Master
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Southeastern USA
Posts: 978
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Softail Vs Dyna
The softail standard and the duece really turn me on, but I don't like the B engines, or the hidden suspension.
I'd say the dyna wideglide is in my opinion the best looking bike HD makes, and comes with the added plus (to me at least) of upright shocks and the rubber mounted engine. But you know what they say about opinions.
I guess it all depends on what you're buying it for.
One thing to think about when arguing ride quality. ALL of the touring models have upright shocks. There is a reason. Think about it.
I'd say the dyna wideglide is in my opinion the best looking bike HD makes, and comes with the added plus (to me at least) of upright shocks and the rubber mounted engine. But you know what they say about opinions.
I guess it all depends on what you're buying it for.
One thing to think about when arguing ride quality. ALL of the touring models have upright shocks. There is a reason. Think about it.
#24
12-03-2006, 10:42 AM
RE: Softail Vs Dyna
Another consideration, is how tall are you ? I took more time than most to shop around. I rode, sat on everything I could for a year and a half. I waffled between the Deuce, and the Wide Glide when it came down to it. But for straight up comfort right off of the show room floor it was the W.G. I'm a little over 6'2". I have a 36 inch inseam, and there isn't a softail made that had forward enough controls for me to get comfy on. As far as the balanced motor being smoother, I can honestly say that my mirrors are as smooth as glass at highway speeds. I love my Dyna, the ONLY thing I would own other than another Dyna, is a touring bike. I kind of wish I'd have bought the Road King Custom, or the Street Glide. Lord willing I'll have a bike with bags after I get old
, LOL, I just know someone will take offense to that.
, LOL, I just know someone will take offense to that.
#25
12-03-2006, 10:48 AM
RE: Softail Vs Dyna
And then theres the therey that upright shocks clutter up the flow or the lines of the bike. Notice how maney true customs dont have upright shocks......There is a reason....Think about it
ORIGINAL: Psycho
The softail standard and the duece really turn me on, but I don't like the B engines, or the hidden suspension.
I'd say the dyna wideglide is in my opinion the best looking bike HD makes, and comes with the added plus (to me at least) of upright shocks and the rubber mounted engine. But you know what they say about opinions.
I guess it all depends on what you're buying it for.
One thing to think about when arguing ride quality. ALL of the touring models have upright shocks. There is a reason. Think about it.
The softail standard and the duece really turn me on, but I don't like the B engines, or the hidden suspension.
I'd say the dyna wideglide is in my opinion the best looking bike HD makes, and comes with the added plus (to me at least) of upright shocks and the rubber mounted engine. But you know what they say about opinions.
I guess it all depends on what you're buying it for.
One thing to think about when arguing ride quality. ALL of the touring models have upright shocks. There is a reason. Think about it.
#26
12-03-2006, 10:56 AM
Road Master
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Southeastern USA
Posts: 978
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Softail Vs Dyna
ORIGINAL: HD7585
And then theres the therey that upright shocks clutter up the flow or the lines of the bike. Notice how maney true customs dont have upright shocks......There is a reason....Think about it
And then theres the therey that upright shocks clutter up the flow or the lines of the bike. Notice how maney true customs dont have upright shocks......There is a reason....Think about it
ORIGINAL: Psycho
The softail standard and the duece really turn me on, but I don't like the B engines, or the hidden suspension.
I'd say the dyna wideglide is in my opinion the best looking bike HD makes, and comes with the added plus (to me at least) of upright shocks and the rubber mounted engine. But you know what they say about opinions.
I guess it all depends on what you're buying it for.
One thing to think about when arguing ride quality. ALL of the touring models have upright shocks. There is a reason. Think about it.
The softail standard and the duece really turn me on, but I don't like the B engines, or the hidden suspension.
I'd say the dyna wideglide is in my opinion the best looking bike HD makes, and comes with the added plus (to me at least) of upright shocks and the rubber mounted engine. But you know what they say about opinions.
I guess it all depends on what you're buying it for.
One thing to think about when arguing ride quality. ALL of the touring models have upright shocks. There is a reason. Think about it.
Also of cosideration is how much two up riding he plans to do.
#27
12-03-2006, 11:01 AM
Road Master
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Southeastern USA
Posts: 978
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Softail Vs Dyna
ORIGINAL: jaysonL
Another consideration, is how tall are you ? I took more time than most to shop around. I rode, sat on everything I could for a year and a half. I waffled between the Deuce, and the Wide Glide when it came down to it. But for straight up comfort right off of the show room floor it was the W.G. I'm a little over 6'2". I have a 36 inch inseam, and there isn't a softail made that had forward enough controls for me to get comfy on. As far as the balanced motor being smoother, I can honestly say that my mirrors are as smooth as glass at highway speeds. I love my Dyna, the ONLY thing I would own other than another Dyna, is a touring bike. I kind of wish I'd have bought the Road King Custom, or the Street Glide. Lord willing I'll have a bike with bags after I get old, LOL, I just know someone will take offense to that.
Another consideration, is how tall are you ? I took more time than most to shop around. I rode, sat on everything I could for a year and a half. I waffled between the Deuce, and the Wide Glide when it came down to it. But for straight up comfort right off of the show room floor it was the W.G. I'm a little over 6'2". I have a 36 inch inseam, and there isn't a softail made that had forward enough controls for me to get comfy on. As far as the balanced motor being smoother, I can honestly say that my mirrors are as smooth as glass at highway speeds. I love my Dyna, the ONLY thing I would own other than another Dyna, is a touring bike. I kind of wish I'd have bought the Road King Custom, or the Street Glide. Lord willing I'll have a bike with bags after I get old
, LOL, I just know someone will take offense to that.
I did have a little vibe trouble at one time, but the MoCo replaced the front motor mount, and aligned the bike. That eliminated the vibe.
The softails buzz me. After an hour or so my hands are buzzing. Feels like someone is hitting the frame repeatedly with a hammer.
Like it's been said so many times. Best way to pick a harley is to rent everything you are considering for at least a full day, and really put some miles on it. Then buy what YOU want.
#28
12-03-2006, 11:24 AM
Intermediate
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Ohio
Posts: 45
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#29
12-03-2006, 11:33 AM
Outstanding HDF Member
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Between Chicago & Milwaukee
Posts: 3,043
Received 111 Likes
on
48 Posts
RE: Softail Vs Dyna
ORIGINAL: Psycho
Mines smooth at speed as well. I've got the classic harley shake at idle of course, but once at speed, it disappears.
I did have a little vibe trouble at one time, but the MoCo replaced the front motor mount, and aligned the bike. That eliminated the vibe.
The softails buzz me. After an hour or so my hands are buzzing. Feels like someone is hitting the frame repeatedly with a hammer.
Like it's been said so many times. Best way to pick a harley is to rent everything you are considering for at least a full day, and really put some miles on it. Then buy what YOU want.
Mines smooth at speed as well. I've got the classic harley shake at idle of course, but once at speed, it disappears.
I did have a little vibe trouble at one time, but the MoCo replaced the front motor mount, and aligned the bike. That eliminated the vibe.
The softails buzz me. After an hour or so my hands are buzzing. Feels like someone is hitting the frame repeatedly with a hammer.
Like it's been said so many times. Best way to pick a harley is to rent everything you are considering for at least a full day, and really put some miles on it. Then buy what YOU want.
I went back and forth between the Softail and Dyna forums frequently,It was reading about the problems some Dyna riders experience with motor mounts that finally made my decision for me.
Not sure why,but I haven't experienced the "Softail buzz" at all,not even slightly but I've seen it mentioned by several riders in the forum.
Above all else,like Psycho said...the best thing is to test ride 'em.
