Whelp, I broke my indicator bezel (again) while relocating my speedo back to the stock handlebar clamp set up. Also, it looks like that part has gotten near impossible to find (#68513-95A). Is it possible that the newer ones would fit in my 04? Like this one, which I think is an 07 and up?

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Harley-Davidson-Sportster-1200-883-Custom-Speedometer-Indicator-Light-Cover-/263204636680?hash=item3d48380808:gHcAAOSwH1lZuSy C&vxp=mtr

 

That bezel became part of an "assembly", with the bezel stand-alone part going obsolete, IIRC.
Try this part #. Should be a lot less than 25 bucks:
68382-96 BEZEL ASSEMBLY, indicator lamps
Here's a link to an assembly diagram. The language doesn't matter. The part numbers are there:
http://www.speed-parts.ru/shop.php/l...el/6996/119054
$8 at New Castle:
https://shop.newcastlehd.com/part/68382-96

 

yep, thank you Scuba, looks like the same part, just updated number for newer Sportsters. It'd be awesome if they didn't make it out of plastic!