When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Mutazu owner here too and I'm more than satisfied. Granted, mine's the chopped pack, but overall I think it's put together well at a fraction of the cost. Good luck with whatever you go with.
I've fixed/repaired/painted several tourpacks both HD and aftermarket. The aftermarket ones (all seem to made the same) are a bit flimsy compared to the HD. If you add the light to the rear(if it did not come with it) it will give it some support. If you can do your own painting, then you could probably repair a damaged one off Ebay fairly easily. ABS and fiberglass both are very easy to repair, and you can usually find some with minor damage. Also check with some larger HD dealers, they often have some with mild damage they may sell (Ray Price HD In Raleigh has a salvage parts business next to the dealership).
I would try craigslist. I bought 2 from there for 500 each. One was the new style for my 2016 road glide. you need to check daily, good deals go quick.
I purchased a king Mutazu last year. I have it attached to a quick release so it's not on the bike full time, but I have over 17,000 miles touring and have not experienced any issues.
Pretty popular question lately, this must be the fifth thread asking about Mutazu tour packs in the last two months. Love mine, had it for years with no issues. Most of the negatives on this forum are from members that have never owned a mutazu pack or don't have pictures to show the issues they had. Plenty of pics of the satisfied owners!
The last picture was from our three week 6800 mile road trip me and my wife went on in 2013, very packed down and it didn't have any issues.