Dealing with H-Q ?
As for the OP, Troop, is your name Jeff? I ask because Kevin is a good friend of mine and he mentioned the exchange of emails he's had with someone named Jeff who was interested in buying HQ 525 cams for a 103 using SE flat top cast pistons and a .040 head gasket intially. Jeff didn't know until Kevin explained that the piston was at negative deck height and that gasket would yield about .050 quench which would cause serious preignition.
Kevin also explained to "Jeff" why an HQ forged piston would be superior to the SE cast piston and why adjustables would be superior to the stock push rods when using a thinner than stock head gasket.
If Troop is "Jeff," his last email (of a series of emails asking questions which Kevin answered) to Kevin on March 9th closed with this: " Again, thank you for all of your help..Jeff"
So Troop, or Jeff, your original post is garbage. Kevin suggested you use different parts and told you why. You apparently don't care to accept his answers and choose to throw him under the bus on a public forum with an essentially misleading account of your experience with him.
If you aren't Jeff, you have my sincere apology. If you are Jeff, Kevin will probably be happy you aren't a customer; I know I would be.
Carl
Last edited by troop; Mar 12, 2010 at 06:49 AM.
I don't understand why they make their customers work hard to buy their product. They're not selling anything, just taking orders. They won't be taking mine. I can't believe they expect you to be sold on a product by posting questions on an internet forum. Seriously. If they had given me the opportunity to talk to them, I would have purchased a 107 kit already, way back when I first got my '10. I was ready to spend the cash, but they left me with negative feelings after a couple of emails.
If they're too lazy or too cheap to hire someone to sell their products and provide customer support, then forget them. I won't give them my money.
I would post the emails here if I had no respect for anyone. But, I am not an *** and there are always two sides to a story. Maybe someone was having a bad week when they emailed me. I dunno...
Last edited by JCleary; Mar 12, 2010 at 09:17 AM.
"SE pistons are bad for several reasons, including instability due to
narrow wrist pin, and the negative deck height they all have on 103". Add a .040 gasket and you just increased the probability of auto/preignition tenfold! You'd have .050 quench....BAD NEWS! Regardless of compression ratio." [NOTE: At this point in your emails to and from Kevin, you hadn't told him you had already purchased the SE pistons, so he suggested HQ's pistons to you.]
His reply to you was in response to your "plan" to use stock push rods (because you had heard adjustables break or loosen), and a .040 head gasket:
"Hi Kevin, Thanks for the reply. I've just read about incidents with
adjustables loosening/cracking/etc that using the stockers is a safer way
to go. As far as the .040 head gasket, I also thought that that thickness
would also be a safer way to go with some of today's fuel at the expense
of a bit less exhaust scavenging. The .040/stock pushrods sounded like a
safe bet."
Another problem with your OP was and remains that your "plan" didn't have any sense of urgency to it; in fact, you told Kevin you were not in a hurry:
"What I am having trouble finding are results with the use of this cam. I hear "forum" members express + thoughts/opinions but I haven't seen anything yet? This isn't a problem as I'm not in a hurry to get the build done. I also need to accumulate compression releases, hd clutch spring, primary gasket, cam service kit, etc. I just have to decide on a cam, knowing exactly what I can expect out of it with my 103"/.030/10.1:1 cr I know I ask a lot of questions but you are the expert source I need to go to regarding the 525's as I can't find much user info on them. Again, thank you for all of your help..Jeff"
The quoted email was sent by you to Kevin on Tuesday of this week; on Thursday you throw Kevin under the bus claiming he's not responsive and he's just pushing parts on you with no explanation. Those claims are false. Your subsequent post in which you acknowledge you are "Jeff" doesn't acknowledge that Kevin explained his reasons for his recommendations. If you were to really "man up" you would have acknowledged Kevin did more in his responses to you than push parts, and acknowledge that he never told you to sell the SE pistons.
I have no problems with customers of any vendor asking questions (shoot, most of us, including me, are ignorant about many of the products, not just cams,) we are considering for our bikes) or for complaining about a vendor who is not responsive provided the information regarding the communications between potential customer and vendor are fairly/accurately reported. In this specific case, the communications weren't fairly and accurately reported.
Carl
I don't understand why they make their customers work hard to buy their product. They're not selling anything, just taking orders. They won't be taking mine. I can't believe they expect you to be sold on a product by posting questions on an internet forum. Seriously. If they had given me the opportunity to talk to them, I would have purchased a 107 kit already, way back when I first got my '10. I was ready to spend the cash, but they left me with negative feelings after a couple of emails.
If they're too lazy or too cheap to hire someone to sell their products and provide customer support, then forget them. I won't give them my money.
I would post the emails here if I had no respect for anyone. But, I am not an *** and there are always two sides to a story. Maybe someone was having a bad week when they emailed me. I dunno...
For those of us that have had no issues, I guess it is really what the individuals perception is of customer service. Doug is actually out in the shop doing the work, and the quality is excellent. Kevin has set up the new Protwin website for retail sales, and there are a couple of ways to reach him through the website and through the HQ forum. I do know at times I get a busy signal, but that happens at all shops. He does return calls.
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders







