Need Advice Stage 1 Intake Options
The HD factory remaps don't buy you anything worthwhile besides setting things back to factory calibrations. If you want full benefit from stage 1 modification dollars, you need to tune the bike. A canned MAP won't cut it, especially one with HD constraints.
The "little" adjustment capability is BS, the Delphi ECU has a 20% range.... but I hear you may bump into these limits with the more sophisticated exhaust and intake systems.
There is a bit of torque impact bottom end that is worth the sound, but killing is way too strong a statement, the factory download does nothing there anyway. There are better ways to adjust that rev limiter for racing purposes.
Plug and play works for me. I will let them suggest a hi flow air cleaner for me.
Plug and play works for me. I will let them suggest a hi flow air cleaner for me.
Just saying that you may be repeating the mistake that many here have been through. You are starting out from scratch with a sophisticated 2010 model bike and want to band aid it and compromise its ECU. There are many here happy with a PC (the PCV is much better BTW) and many more here that have regretted buying one (driveability and reliability issues) and not doing it right from the first.
If you are looking for less money, the V&H fuel pack also has many happy customers. The nightrider.com site does a good job selling the XiEDs and they may be sufficient to make you happy. Any of the add on modules do liven up the bike in a narrow envelope, especially WOT power, but they also leave a lot of performance on the table. PCs also cripple the ECUs capability to adapt to the crap fuel you may get now and then, not as much of a worry years ago. When you ride a tuned bike you wonder why you ever put one of those band aids on, especially when you can get a pretty good tuning kit for about $400.
You need to look at what you are really trying to do here, seems silly to me to compromise performance just to save $200 on a $15000 bike that has over $500 in modifications.... but that just may be me. Its your money and your judgment call, but unfortunately no right answer for everyone. Lots of marketing hype and old wives tales out there to sort through, not to mention shills here now and again touting the virtues of one product or another.
If I had a dollar for every one of these comments I've read: Whichever you decide on make sure you use dielectric grease on the connectors. I washed my bike a couple of weeks ago and PCV got wet and messed up on me. They're sending me another one this week.
Last edited by ColdCase; Jul 14, 2010 at 06:27 AM.
Just saying that you may be repeating the mistake that many here have been through. You are starting out from scratch with a sophisticated 2010 model bike and want to band aid it. There are many here happy with a PC and many more here that have regretted buying one and not doing it right.
If you are looking for less money, the V&H fuel pack also has many happy customers. The nightrider.com site does a good job selling the XiEDs and they may be sufficient to make you happy. Any of the add on modules do liven up the bike in a narrow envelope, especially WOT power, but they also leave a lot of performance on the table. PCs also cripple the ECUs capability to adapt to the crap fuel you may get now and then, not as much of a worry years ago. When you ride a tuned bike you wonder why you ever put one of those band aids on, especially when you can get a pretty good tuning kit for about $400.
You need to look at what you are really trying to do here, seems silly to me to compromise performance just to save $200 on a $15000 bike that has over $500 in modifications.... but that just may be me. Its your money and your judgment call, but unfortunately no right answer for everyone. Lots of marketing hype and old wives tales out there to sort through, not to mention shills here now and again touting the virtues of one product or another.
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders
The consensus best way is to hire a competent tuner (usually independent). The hardest part is finding a competent tuner that's worth his salt. There are a few nationally known centers but I don't know of a list published anywhere. This is one reason those of us that don't mind tinkering a little bit, like to use the TTS kit. Even a novice can easily get a get a good tune, better performing for your kind of riding than a pre-canned generic map.
There is a sticky over in the EFI forum about what to look for, but a good sign is the tuner recommends use a TTS kit and has high quality wideband sensor equipped dynos. Post your city in the EFI forum and perhaps one of the nationally known tuning centers are nearby. Another good sign is if he asks what you want out of the bike, raw power, street driveability, economy as the tune can be optimized.
https://www.hdforums.com/forum/elect...-injection-55/
Auto Tuners that use wide band O2 sensors to control AFR sound good, but I hear that in practice they don't really perform as advertised.
The best would be a competent tuner w/a TTS or SESTP.



