Everyone seems to have given some excellent advice here. The unfortunate thing here is you are missing the opportunity to sit on one and see for yourself. I knew from the moment I sat on my 06 Bob that it felt perfect. The seat sits low and just feels perfect to me whether I'm riding or waiting at a railroad crossing for 5 minutes. Someone mentioned in an earlier post that the St Bob was an excellent starter bike for someone's first Harley. I take no offense to that and tend to agree, although Iwouldn't classify it as a starter bike. I've been fortunate enough to ride all types of bikes, from Sportsters to two-wheeled sofas. I can't think ofany reasonto not recommend the St Bob. I think by far the toughest (and best) decision has already been made. You've narrowed it down to a Dyna, and plain and simple, Dyna's offer the most bang for your buck. Thanks for your service - ride safe - J