Something went CLUNK!!!
I'm going to start by removing the primary, to get to the entire shifter linkage. Hopefully, the answer will be staring me in the face at that point. But, if not, I'll go as deep as I need to. Spring's-a-coming, and I don't intend on relying on my POS ranger to get to work for the next long while.
I plan on getting some photos up of the process, and, just maybe, this may help someone else out in the future.
In the meantime, if anyone has experienced this sort of thing before, by all means, speak up. If you can help narrow the possibilities, that sure would be a big help!
But before going further and barring any obvious linkage problems other things to look at are the pawl adjustment screw which may have come loose or is wildly out of adjustment. You can check and re-adjust the pawl adjustment without removing the primary. You might need to cut down an Allen wrench to make it fit between the inner primary and transmission though. Pawl adjustment simplified is put the transmission into third gear, loosen the pawl adjustment lock nut, turn the pawl adjustment screw one way or the other with the Allen wrench (just a little bit) until the shifter arm on the transmission (the arm the linkage rod is attached to) moves an equal distance forward and back before encountering any resistance.
If that's not the problem pull the top lid off the transmission and visually check the pawl spring. You'll be able to see the top of it and that's usually where it breaks. Here's some photos of one I worked on that broke.

After I pulled the transmission from the bike I turned it upside down and let it drain out all the oil overnight. The next morning I found the rest of the spring bits in the drained oil.

Like someone said upboard the problem now is those broken bits probably migrated through the gears. You can visually inspect them but unless you have a microscope, lol, it's a crapshoot you won't have a gear tooth problem later on. Changing out the pawl spring is a big job that requires a bit of know how so hopefully your issue is something simpler.
Here's something to help you with the pawl adjustment: (This shows the trans out of the bike, but you can still do it while its installed.)

But before going further and barring any obvious linkage problems other things to look at are the pawl adjustment screw which may have come loose or is wildly out of adjustment. You can check and re-adjust the pawl adjustment without removing the primary. You might need to cut down an Allen wrench to make it fit between the inner primary and transmission though. Pawl adjustment simplified is put the transmission into third gear, loosen the pawl adjustment lock nut, turn the pawl adjustment screw one way or the other with the Allen wrench (just a little bit) until the shifter arm on the transmission (the arm the linkage rod is attached to) moves an equal distance forward and back before encountering any resistance.
If that's not the problem pull the top lid off the transmission and visually check the pawl spring. You'll be able to see the top of it and that's usually where it breaks. Here's some photos of one I worked on that broke.

After I pulled the transmission from the bike I turned it upside down and let it drain out all the oil overnight. The next morning I found the rest of the spring bits in the drained oil.

Like someone said upboard the problem now is those broken bits probably migrated through the gears. You can visually inspect them but unless you have a microscope, lol, it's a crapshoot you won't have a gear tooth problem later on. Changing out the pawl spring is a big job that requires a bit of know how so hopefully your issue is something simpler.
Here's something to help you with the pawl adjustment: (This shows the trans out of the bike, but you can still do it while its installed.)


Trending Topics
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders
I'm going to start by removing the primary, to get to the entire shifter linkage. Hopefully, the answer will be staring me in the face at that point. But, if not, I'll go as deep as I need to. Spring's-a-coming, and I don't intend on relying on my POS ranger to get to work for the next long while.
I plan on getting some photos up of the process, and, just maybe, this may help someone else out in the future.
In the meantime, if anyone has experienced this sort of thing before, by all means, speak up. If you can help narrow the possibilities, that sure would be a big help!






