Starter Problems - Harley Davidson Forums

Ironhead A place to talk about Ironheads.

Starter Problems

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 04-28-2012, 07:19 PM
svkidd's Avatar
svkidd svkidd is offline
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: San Diego
Posts: 5
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default Starter Problems

Any info would be great.. I just picked up a basketcase 74 ironhead got the motor all together when I try to start it the motor turns over once then the starter kicks out. when I take the plugs out the motor will turn over just fine. Anybody had this issue..
Reply With Quote
Old 04-28-2012, 07:35 PM
IronMick's Avatar
IronMick IronMick is offline
Outstanding HDF Member
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: London, ON Canada
Posts: 2,885
Thanked 25 Times in 25 Posts

First possibility is the battery. If it either is low on charge or will not pass a load test then this may happen. Run thru items 1 thru 4 in this ...

IronHead Charging System Checkout

You need a multimeter. The digital ones are best and can be had for less than $10.00. A voltmeter is a multimeter set to measure DC volts. An ammeter is a multimeter set to read DC current in amps. The ohmmeter section of the multimeter will test for continuity. Continuity means that current may flow between the two points.

I find alligator clip probes are much more convenient than pointer probes. Occasionally a pointer probe is better so i have a set of each.

When using a Multimeter, if the object fails a test, repeat the test ensuring that you have good connections with the meter probes, especially to a good ground.

1. Fully charge battery.

It is not good enough to put it on a charger overnight and assume it is fully charged. Some batteries will take 24 hours to fully charge. The way to know for sure is to do a specific gravity test [for liquid filled batteries], or to use an automatic battery charger.

I have heard that you should never use a battery charger greater than 2 amps for any motorcycle; that it is best to use between .75 and 1.5 amps. Best are the automatic chargers such as Battery Minder or Battery Tender.

2A. Cell test battery [not for maintenance-free batteries].

Remove caps from battery cells. Keep the red voltmeter lead on a terminal and insert the black lead progressively into each cell, far enough that it contacts the plates. You should get readings of 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12 volts. If one cell does not contribute its proper 2 volts then that cell is dead and the battery is no good.

2B. Load test battery.

It is said that, with electronic ignition, you should never crank the engine without grounded plugs attached to the wires. For this test you should install an extra set of plugs into the wires and set them onto the top cylinder head fins.

Disconnect both spark plugs. Attach voltmeter leads to the battery terminals. Crank the engine for 10 seconds [no more!]. Observe the meter WHILE cranking. If it goes below 10 volts then the battery is no good. Alternatively you can buy an expensive battery load tester.

Bring the battery up to full charge again before proceeding.

3A. Current Drain Test #1

Disconnect the battery -ve cable from the battery. Connect the ammeter between battery -ve post and the battery cable. It should read .003 amps or less.

3B. Current Drain Test #2

Disconnect the +ve terminal from the battery. Connect an automotive test light between the battery and the cable. If light comes on there is a current draw.

Note: To determine which circuit is faulty disconnect the circuit breakers or remove the fuses one at a time. When the light goes out you know which circuit is the problem.

3C. Battery Cables Test

With voltmeter connected to battery terminals check voltage while cranking. Then with voltmeter on battery cables check voltage while cranking. If voltage drop due to cranking [should not go below 10 volts] is different cables may be bad or there may be corrosion.

Here is another very simple non complex test you can do if you suspect that something is draining your battery when the key is off. This applies to bikes that have no digital instrumentation (like ironheads). Unhook your negative battery terminal. Touch the wire back to the negative battery terminal, there should be no spark when you do. If it arks and sparks (like a downed hydro pole in a rain storm in a horror movie) then something is drawing power when it shouldn't be.

4. Charging System Test

Measure the battery voltage with the bike not running. It should be at least 12.x; preferably it will be 13.x.

Measure the voltage with the bike idling at about 2000 to 3000 RPM. It should be at least 1.0 volts higher than the not-running reading, otherwise the charging system is not charging the battery. It should be at least 13.x, preferably 14.x.

5. Regulator Test

Disconnect the regulator. Connect your ohmmeter to the orange and tan wires. Note the reading. Reverse the connections. Note the reading. One reading should show continuity, the other should show no continuity. If the regulator does not pass this test it is no good. This is the circuit that prevents the reg from draining the batt when the bike sits overnight.

This test only tests one circuit in the regulator, so even if it passes this test it may still be no good. There are other tests of the regulator that require specialized equipment. These tests are in the factory and Clymer manuals. I recommend taking both the reg and the gen to an automotive electric repair shop for testing if needed. Note: these shops usually want to test both parts together.

6. Generator Test #1: Residual Magnetism

Disconnect both the A and F terminal wires. Connect the +ve voltmeter lead to the A and the -ve lead to ground. Run the engine at about 2000 RPM. The meter should read at least 2.0 volts. If the voltage is low polarize the generator and repeat the test. If the generator fails this test it must be disassembled for repair.

7. Generator Test #2: Maximum Output

Remove both the A and F terminal wires. Connect the +ve voltmeter lead to the A and the -ve lead to ground. Run the engine at about 2000 RPM. MOMENTARILY [not longer than 10 seconds] connect a jumper lead from ground to F and read the meter. The meter should read 25 to 30 volts DC. If the generator fails this test it must be disassembled for repair.

8. Generator Test #3: Amperes Output
  1. Remove all wires from both A and F terminals
  2. run a jumper from F to a good ground on the motorcycle
  3. run a jumper from A to ammeter +ve
  4. run the engine at 2000 RPM
  5. momentarily jumper from battery +ve to ammeter -ve
  6. ammeter should read 10 amps or more
If the generator fails this test it must be disassembled for repair.

9. Here's a good way to bench test your generator:

1. connect a jumper from the "+" battery post to the "A" armature terminal on the gen.
2. Connect a jumper from the "-" battery post to the "F" field terminal of the gen.
3. Now take a third jumper from the "-" battery post and touch it to the case of the gen.

If all is well the generator will run like an electric motor. With the gen gear pointing away from you the rotation is clockwise.

Don't try this with the generator on the bike.

10. Polarizing the Generator

With the generator fully installed in the bike, all connections made, ignition off; connect one end of a jumper wire to the gen A, and momentarily touch the other end to the battery +ve terminal.

Usually [but not always they say], you will get a spark at the battery terminal and a light clunk sound from the gen.

11. Polarizing the Generator - The Complete Story

1. with the gen on the bench
[i] jumper the gen A to batt +ve
[ii] momentarily jumper from gen F to batt -ve

Note: This can be done the other way around,
[i] jumper gen F to the -ve batt
[ii] momentarily jumper gen A to batt +ve

2. with the gen on the bike, wires not connected
[i] jumper from gen F to a good ground
[ii] momentarily jumper from gen A to batt +ve

Note: This technique is preferred over #3 because the good ground is better than relying on grounding the F thru the reg.
Note: As with #1 this can be done the other way around.

3. with the gen on the bike, all wires connected
[i] momentarily jumper gen A to batt +ve

Note: This is technically the same as techniques #1 and #2 as the F is grounded thru the reg.

4. For bikes with a mechanical reg [1959 to 1977]

Momentarily jumper between BAT and GEN on the reg.

Note: this is technically the same as all of the other techniques as BAT is connected to batt +ve and GEN is connected to gen A.

5. For bikes with a Cycle Electric Generator/Regulator

On the Cycle Electric DGV-5000 generators you have to remove the brush cover and touch a wire from the positive terminal of the battery to the positive brush lead of the generator to polarize it. You can't polarize the generator from the external terminals. (One of the terminals is the battery terminal, and the other has an internal diode.)
You have to try pretty hard to reverse the polarity on those generators and they rarely need to be polarized.

For clarification: Cycle Electric does have a voltage regulator (the CE-540) which looks very similar. It will bolt up to a standard Model 65A generator and has external leads which connect externally between the regulator and the generator.
The CE-500 bolts to a Cycle Electric DGV-5000 generator and the regulator is internally wired to the generator.
- With the CE-540 setup the generator can be polarized by running a lead from the battery + to the "A" terminal.
- With the CE-500 you need to polarize the generator at the positive brush lead.

12. Generator Brushes Assembly: Dismantle, Cleaning, Repair

1. The brushes holder and related parts can be dismantled without removing the gen from the bike. This is useful because, in my [limited] experience, if the gen light is coming on then one or both of the brushes is probably sticking. This can be easy to fix.

I am writing this from memory, not while doing it. I think i have the removal process right.

Remove gen end cap. Remove the bracket and brush cover strap. Remove the commutator end cover. There are 3 screws visible. Two just hold the brushes to the brush holder; these do not need to be removed. The third screw attaches a wire from inside the gen to the brush assembly. Remove this screw. Now the brush assembly can be removed.

Usually it is quite dirty in there so at this point i use a spray can of electrical contacts cleaner to clean up the mess.

The brushes will spring out of the brush holder. They must be each longer than 1/2 inch else replace both. Reinstall each temporarily and work them between thumb and finger to see if there is any binding.

To re-install brushes in holder use long twist ties from the kitchen. Pick out the twist ties after the holder is re-installed.

2. To remove the gen from the bike: Disconnect the wires from the A and F terminals; remove the two bolts from the gearcase side; raise the inner end toward the 11:00 o'clock position, lower the outer end toward the 5:00 o'clock position, and remove carefully.

For the rest you really need a manual. The FM is very good. It is usually not necessary to remove the gen drive gear - this requires a gear puller to remove. The rest of the gen dismantles quite easily.

Once opened up you can do more cleaning and inspection; again using the spray can electrical contacts cleaner.

The FM contains a number of tests that you can easily do once it is opened up: field coil test, shorted or open field test, grounded armature test, and open armature test.

The shorted armature test requires special equipment which a shop would have [a growler]. Doing actual repair may require special equipment such as a lathe, and perhaps experienced hands.
Reply With Quote
Old 04-29-2012, 08:41 AM
Bama91's Avatar
Bama91 Bama91 is offline
Senior Rider
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Reidsville, NC
Posts: 349
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

As Mick says above. Also check out a heavy duty starter. Since it was a basket case and I am assuming you rebuilt the engine, the compression may be too much for the starter. A burned armature can also cause this. If the armature is burned (blue) I would buy a new starter rather than go with a rebuild and turn due to a long start will easily burn it again.
Reply With Quote
Old 04-29-2012, 11:24 AM
svkidd's Avatar
svkidd svkidd is offline
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: San Diego
Posts: 5
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

Thanks for the quick responses I will look into a new started and keep you posted...
Reply With Quote
Old 05-27-2012, 01:50 AM
svkidd's Avatar
svkidd svkidd is offline
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: San Diego
Posts: 5
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default another starter motor

I have just installed another starter motor with exactly the same results.... Battery is fine im unclear how the starter motor can spin but not be engaged sense the solinoid has to be pulled in to make the connection for the starter motor..??
Reply With Quote
Old 05-27-2012, 07:53 AM
IronMick's Avatar
IronMick IronMick is offline
Outstanding HDF Member
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: London, ON Canada
Posts: 2,885
Thanked 25 Times in 25 Posts

What are the results of running thru steps 1 thru 4 of the Charging System Checkout procedure?

The operation of the mechanism in the starter shaft housing [AKA the bendix assembly, the starter clutch assembly, starter pinion gear assembly, or starter drive gear unit] is a bit complex. It is responsible for the gear on the end of the starter shaft [not the starter motor shaft] engaging the starter ring gear on the clutch sprocket.

The terminology is confusing. You need to examine the schematic diagrams in the factory parts catalog 99451-78B and the info in the factory service manual 99484-78, or have someone other than myself explain it.

The solenoid is only part of the action. It just makes the electrical connection. The bendix, shift lever, etc is resonsible for the engagement with the ring gear. The assembly will not function unless the battery is not only fully charged, but also able to handle the very heavy load involved in this process.

So please do those steps 1 thru 4. And please ensure that the battery is truely fully charged for both parts as outlined in the procedure.
Reply With Quote

Related Topics
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
1974 Ironhead Sportster Starter Issue Chaoszen Ironhead 1 08-25-2013 08:02 PM
Shovelhead starter John1957 Shovelhead 12 09-22-2012 05:13 PM
Starter problems 89 FXRS Evo Classic Models 12 06-17-2012 05:16 PM
Starter problem please help liljon140 Sportster Models 12 04-06-2012 07:24 PM
1980 starter slugbug Ironhead 4 07-16-2006 12:27 AM

74, ammeter, basket, case, davidson, fxr, harley, install, ironhead, problems, reinstalled, start, starter, starters, sticks, troubleshooting, wont

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

Forum Jump

Featured Sponsors
Vendor Directory

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:36 PM.

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.
  • Ask a Question
    Get answers from community experts
Question Title:
Your question will be posted in: