I was torn between the two also but went with the Night Train. I put a sundowner bucket seat on it and me and the misses can ride for about two hours together, Ive logged 600 miles in one day solo with it, so you can make them comfortable. I couldn't get over the fat front tire so my bike is at the shop right now waiting on a 17" X 3.5" new front wheel. Couple other people on here have done the fat front tire also and it looks pretty good, IMHO. Just go with whever one you like the overall look of better, they're both softails so they'll both ride great, just be ready to dump a ton of money to make it look perfect for yourself.

 

I think the seat has a lot to do with how you "sit" on/in the bike. I have a fairly small seat but find it very comfortable. It allows me to sit "in" or so I think. The bike is alsolowered a bit in the rear.