XIED????
I personally feel the X version flirts with the edges of what the O2 sensor can reliably report.
With any such device, it would be nice if they could only enrich the closed-loop areas of operation. But with our current engine management systems, they will also increase fuel the same amount in the open-loop areas of operation, where our bikes really do not need any additional fuel to begin with.
It is a pretty cheap way to spend a little more on fuel to cool the motor down some. I suggest that they have their best value for those who have not modified their intakes/exhausts and most always use the engine lightly-enough to keep it in closed-loop operation.
Installing aftermarket intakes/exhausts without somehow correcting the fuel needs is problematic enough by itself, and installing these devices on top of that situation can make it better or worse. Sometimes both together. If other means of correcting the fueling requirements of add-on stuff are used, these devices are not necessary.
In summary, I would say they have their best value for being the least intrusive and best effective on factory-stock running gear.
Thanks Nightrider! Happy customer here.
The factory O2 sensors only affect the closed loop section of the ecm so the XiED or IED only affects the closed loop portion of the bike. It cant affect the open loop portion because the O2 sensors dont work on that. Hope that was simple enough to understand.
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders
glens is mistaken xied only ritchen it in the closed loop mode thats the only time the puter reads the o2 sensors.
What you are doing with the IEDs is effectively the same as either lowering the fuel pressure or clogging the injectors as far as the ECU is concerned. It adapts to the situation and fires the injectors longer. It assumes the problem affects the entire operational range of the engine and accommodates the problem everywhere.
In the case of the IEDs, it has been fooled into believing that there is a fuel-flow problem so it sprays more fuel into the cylinders because there is in fact no problem. That is why you are getting more fuel in the closed-loop areas. It is also why you are getting more fuel in the open-loop areas too. Even though the engine didn't need it there.
But that's okay, if that's what you want to do. Really.
I would appreciate you not telling me it's not okay if I don't want to do that. Okay?
Thanks.
Really, you should do some diligent research into the Delphi Adaptive Fueling in use currently on our engines before you make declarations such as I quoted you saying.
Also, the your engine is running lean codes are primarily not the result of exhaust leaks. It has to do with the fact that the O2 sensors only operate linearly over a very narrow range. With the XIEDs they are forced to operate at the very fringe of that range. The way they respond in that part of their range is very temperature-dependant. They almost can handle operating there once they fully come up to full temperature, but before that they can be very inaccurate. Not that they're ever that accurate at that level of O2 anyway, compared to the level of O2 they were designed to operate at.






