Syn oil Vs Reg oil
As someone said earlier, if this was the case then the sliding bearings would not wear as they have so little friction with their surroundings due to this wonder oil. If there was any friction the bearings would simply rotate and not wear. This sounds physically impossible to me.
UltraJay
I first heard this comical idea in 1998 and even though I knew it was false I talked to some petroleum engineers I knew at the local Exxon-Mobil refinery. They thought I was joking, but assured me it was a false notion. I then called Torrington, the well-known bearing manufacturer, and talked to one of their engineers. He said he had not heard anything so preposterous in his career. His response was that if the lubricant was too slick to spin the bearing it would also be too slick to cause wear. Makes sense. He also said the only way a ball or needle bearing could "skate" is in a centrifuge where there is no load on the bearing at all, and that would never happen in an engine. There is always load, even when running in neutral.
Anyway, if they are having bearing failures at that dealership it isn't because of the synthetic oil being used. In my case I was using synthetic oil in the bike I owned in 1998 and continued using it 'til I sold it in 2006. It now has 120k miles on the clock and the heads have never been removed, thus no engine work at all, not even a top-end overhaul. I've also been using synthetic oil exclusively in my '07 bike, except for a brief break-in period, with no problems at 27k. This has to be one of the most asinine and baseless old wives tales I've heard in 45 years of riding bikes, and I'm very surprised it hasn't been relegated to the dust bin of baseless ideas concocted by the uninformed. It is truly idiotic.
To the OP and some others responding to this thread, you guys should do some research on oil if you believe the "skating" myth or any notion that fossil oil is the better choice. Synthetic oil is superior to fossil oil in that it can tolerate higher heat before oxidizing (breaking down). If you must use fossil oil change it more often, like every 2500 miles. Any name-brand synthetic will work well in your HD and can be changed at 5K intervals.
Last edited by iclick; Apr 20, 2009 at 10:22 PM.
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders
This has to be one of the most asinine and baseless old wives tales I've heard in 45 years of riding bikes, and I'm very surprised it hasn't been relegated to the dust bin of baseless ideas concocted by the uninformed. It is truly idiotic.
Synthetic Oil's the best,
Thorey



