Replacement transmission opinions needed
Replacement transmission opinions needed
I have a '78 FXE w/ a 4 speed. A local indy shop owner is recomending I go to a 6 speed. As I've said in previous posts, I'm all for that. He is offering me a Jims 6 speed for $2400 + my old tranny. Baker Transmissions run around $3500. Is the savings of $1100 worth it, or will I be likely to encounter headache after headache? Is quality of Jims good? If so, as good as Baker? One concern I already have is that I have a LSD and Jims website only mentions a RSD for the 6 speed.
Advanced
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
From:
RE: Replacement transmission opinions needed
How is the 4th gear geared compared to the 5 speeds of the newer Harleys? Is there a big difference in the gear ratio? I know the 6 speed makes a difference with the new bikes...
Cruiser
Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 216
Likes: 0
From:
RE: Replacement transmission opinions needed
4th in a 4 spdand 5th in a 5 spd gears are 1:1 so no difference in top end rpm , 6th in a 6 spd is overdrive,now if anyone knows of a 4spd with overdrive let me at it
RE: Replacement transmission opinions needed
Baker says "Our Shovelhead 6-speed overdrive has a 1:1 5th gear and a .86 6th; good for a 500 RPM reduction in cruising RPM on the highway." Jims says, "... first gear being close ratio 2.94, and the last four being the same ratio as a stock 5-speed. 6th gear goes to a .86:1 overdrive." Jims also mentions that the use of 6th gear makes for a 500 RPM drop at 75 MPH. I recognize that cost savings does not always equal true savings.
So the question for me remains, which is the better buy? Jims 6 in a 4 @ $2400 + my old tranny or Baker 6 in a 4 @ $3500 (give or take)?
As for the condition of my current tranny, I offer you this... I went riding with a friend last night, and he said "I know you want to ride, but park it until you can get it fixed!" Sometimes, it won't shift up into gear. Let me tell you, it is thrilling to be out riding with a few of the guys and listen to them ride off as you fight to get into 4th, all the while losing speed. AND... Recently it has started to refuse to drop down into 1st. It "shifts", but nothing hooks up. I grab my clutch, stomp down (the tranny clunks like I have put it in gear), rev my engine and release the clutch, but I don't go anywhere, over and over again. That leaves me sitting at the light that just turned green, pissing off everyone behind me. I can kick it up into second, race the motor and ease away from the stop, but what a pain that is (to both me and my motor). So, if that's what Greybeard Bob means by "Unless its ready to puke...", I would say it's puking and it's time for a new transmission.
I have no interest in a 5 speed. I plan on putting alot of highway miles on and would make use of the overdrive. I have a 35+ mile drive one way to work, and all but about 9 of those miles are on 4 lane divided highway.
So the question for me remains, which is the better buy? Jims 6 in a 4 @ $2400 + my old tranny or Baker 6 in a 4 @ $3500 (give or take)?
As for the condition of my current tranny, I offer you this... I went riding with a friend last night, and he said "I know you want to ride, but park it until you can get it fixed!" Sometimes, it won't shift up into gear. Let me tell you, it is thrilling to be out riding with a few of the guys and listen to them ride off as you fight to get into 4th, all the while losing speed. AND... Recently it has started to refuse to drop down into 1st. It "shifts", but nothing hooks up. I grab my clutch, stomp down (the tranny clunks like I have put it in gear), rev my engine and release the clutch, but I don't go anywhere, over and over again. That leaves me sitting at the light that just turned green, pissing off everyone behind me. I can kick it up into second, race the motor and ease away from the stop, but what a pain that is (to both me and my motor). So, if that's what Greybeard Bob means by "Unless its ready to puke...", I would say it's puking and it's time for a new transmission.
I have no interest in a 5 speed. I plan on putting alot of highway miles on and would make use of the overdrive. I have a 35+ mile drive one way to work, and all but about 9 of those miles are on 4 lane divided highway.
Outstanding HDF Member
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 2,303
Likes: 4
From:
RE: Replacement transmission opinions needed
1100 bucks should cover the items needed to rebuild your 4speed at worst case,maybe even much lessdepending on what is found good/bad.Your bike probably doesnt have the oomphfor a 6speed.And yes Bakers trans are very good.Regear your 4speed or final drive to fit your riding style.A shovelhead with the right parts will run very well.
Trending Topics
Novice
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
From:
RE: Replacement transmission opinions needed
It is a lot of mony what we are talking about. In my opinion I would stick with the 4 speed and rebuild it with the gearing you like. If you are going to spend some money better spend it wise, you work hard for it and can spend it only once.
A couple of weeks ago I found an add on ebay where they offered an 3" belt drive, plates, electric starter, ground plate for a 5-speedand a 5 speed Baker tranny for something like $2300,-. The problem is I can't seem to be able to find the ad. anymore. I know it is an American company.
I have been lookin g for it the last hour.
I know it's out there but can not find it anymore (this will solve all your problems, and save you money).
What the indy offers you sounds a lot like a ripoff. Ask him if he wants to kiss you, I always like some foreplay before i **** someone ;-).
Regards Bootsy
A couple of weeks ago I found an add on ebay where they offered an 3" belt drive, plates, electric starter, ground plate for a 5-speedand a 5 speed Baker tranny for something like $2300,-. The problem is I can't seem to be able to find the ad. anymore. I know it is an American company.
I have been lookin g for it the last hour.
I know it's out there but can not find it anymore (this will solve all your problems, and save you money).
What the indy offers you sounds a lot like a ripoff. Ask him if he wants to kiss you, I always like some foreplay before i **** someone ;-).
Regards Bootsy
HD Forum Stories
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders
7 Surprising Harley-Davidson Products that Are Not Motorcycles
Verdad Gallardo
8 Best Harley-Davidson Motorcycles Ever
Pouria Savadkouei
10 Worst Harley-Davidson Motorcycles Ever
Pouria Savadkouei
Killer Custom's Jail Break Is The Breakout That Refused to Blend In
Verdad Gallardo
Crazy Bunderbike Build Looks Amazing, But Is It Impossible to Ride?
Verdad Gallardo
Harley-Davidson Reveals Super Cool Cafe Racer Concept
Verdad Gallardo
Engraved Rebellion: Inside Bundnerbike's Glam Rock II
Verdad Gallardo
10 Motorcycles You Should Never Buy
Joe Kucinski
10 Things Harley-Davidson Needs to Fix in 2026
Verdad Gallardo
Outstanding HDF Member
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 3,306
Likes: 5
From: Bellville, Tx
RE: Replacement transmission opinions needed
If you are not interested in a heavy 1st gear launch, Put a 24T main drive sprocket on the 4 spd. I've done it to give an effective overdrive in 4th. My Evo had no trouble starting in 2nd gear before the switch so unless you are drag racing the higher ratio 1st gear is no problem. I don't shift to 4th til 55mph and cruise comfortably from there to 80. Works for me!
