1991 FLHS Question

Reply Subscribe

Thread Tools

Search this Thread

May 25, 2022 | 11:45 PM

AbnRanger4

Thread Starter

Advanced

Joined: Jun 2019

Posts: 83

Likes: 25

From: Alabama

1991 FLHS Question

Looking at a 1991 FLHS with 60k miles. Owner has had it for 5 1/2 years. He said it uses 1/2 a quart of oil every 16-20 hours of riding. He said a local shop told him to just add oil and ride it. He’s been riding it that way for 5 years with no issues according to him. He’s asking $4200.

Also found a 1989 FLHS with 96k on it. Looks and runs great but the base gaskets are damp. He’s stuck on $5000 for it.

Thoughts? Any reason why the 91 would use oil like that? Or is it just normal?

May 26, 2022 | 02:28 AM

K. Lindberg

Road Captain

Joined: Jun 2014

Posts: 598

Likes: 376

From: Sweden

All I dear to say is that my '91 did not use any oil.

But then I'm known to be a slow rider.

May 26, 2022 | 06:30 AM

GOGOBECK

Road Warrior

Joined: Apr 2018

Posts: 1,347

Likes: 820

From: Moneta, Virginia

I’d pass on both of those bikes, at the prices they’re asking.

Here in Virginia, prices move with the season. Buy over the winter, sell in the spring.

I picked up an ‘01 Road King w/ 16k on the clock for $6000 in December. It came with a lot of extra stuff that I didn’t want… I’ve sold $850 of take off stuff, and spent $500 on needed maintenance and stuff to make it fit me. I still have a brand new Mustang seat & backrest and a tour pack to sell.

I found several RK’s with similar asking prices before finding the one I bought. I scan FB market place & CL on the regular, I don’t see many good deals presently, but they will be there come November!

May 26, 2022 | 08:08 AM

98hotrodfatboy

Seasoned HDF Member

Joined: Mar 2010

Posts: 21,093

Likes: 7,622

From: Poolville

Both bikes will need a top end job.. Right around $2k.. of you could get the 91 for 3k, it's do it.. I'mI would skip on the 89.. Again unless you get it cheap enough to do the top end but 96k on it it's gonna need other stuff depending on what was and want done to the bike already..

May 27, 2022 | 08:22 AM

IBDAGRIZ

Road Master

Joined: Sep 2013

Posts: 1,054

Likes: 441

From: Tejas

The 91 falls into the weak case issue of the time if I'm not mistaken. Possibly the 89 as well.

Griz

May 27, 2022 | 10:47 AM

BB.No8

Road Captain

Joined: Sep 2018

Posts: 547

Likes: 383

From: Phoenix

Quote:

Originally Posted by IBDAGRIZ

The 91 falls into the weak case issue of the time if I'm not mistaken. Possibly the 89 as well.

Griz

Both of those years had engine case problems. I know 2 people who had to replace engine cases on their '89 models. I think that it was '94 or '95 before HD finally got the engine case issues straightened out.

May 27, 2022 | 07:18 PM

Cam01

Advanced

Joined: May 2022

Posts: 54

Likes: 66

From: Florida

Quote:

Originally Posted by AbnRanger4

Oil consumption on the 91 would make me think worn valve guides or seals. I’d be willing to bet a local shop gave him a quote to do a top end on it and when he asked if he NEEDED to do it they shrugged and said you could just ride it and just keep topping it off. He’s probably going to be willing to deal because in the back of his head he KNOWS it needs a repair and how much it will cost. He’s probably figuring someone desperate for a bike who doesn’t know any better will think ‘Harleys just eat oil’ and buy it.

Offer him a grand less than asking if you are willing to roll the dice that it’s an easy fix or are willing to do the fix yourself, but be aware that this is obviously a bike that going to have a ton of other delayed maintenance as well with this kind of owner.

The 89 sounds less appealing because it’s probably also consuming oil but the owner isn’t telling you or isn’t aware. With that many miles you’d hope to have a list of repairs and receipts and no issues, or a flexible price. Obvious issue like leaking gaskets doesn’t equal firm price to me so I wouldn’t waste the time talking to him anymore.

Personally I’d wait till the season slows down and prices get more normal. Seems like what you’ve got is a few guys trying to catch the summer fever, but everyone with money already has a bike and bought the nicer ones. But that’s just my 2c.