Why All The Hatred ?
In essence, the V-Rod was a softail with a powerful engine. Softails are infamous for their horrible lean angle, s*** brakes, and generally **** poor handling. But the one thing softails did have going for them was classic styling and a very cool look. The V-Rod, on the other hand, looked chunky and cumbersome and like a bad caricature of what it should have been. In short, the V-Rod had all of the bad characteristics of a softail with none of the good.
True, the V-Rod had a lot more power and better brakes. But because it handled so poorly people ended up riding it more or less like a softail. Which is exactly why it never sold well.
Now if you took that engine in put it into something kind of shaped like a Dyna, but with inverted forks (preferably Ohlins), adjustable rear monoshock, Brembo 50's, and a medium fat rear tire, you would have the Harley version of the Arch KRGT-1.
I would buy one of those the day they released it, and I bet a whole lot of other people would too.I would love to have a "performance Harley" that actually performed, and the V-Rod sure wasn't it. The only reason I don't already own a KRGT-1 is because the base price is $80k.
The new Fat Bob has some potential, but it's still quite a stretch to call it a performance motorcycle. It's still fat, stubby, heavy, and even the 114 version is going to be underpowered compared to most any naked bike on the market. Now doing get me wrong, I love fat tires and I do think the new Fat Bob could be made into something pretty cool and unique that performs reasonably well. However, I have no illusions that it would take some serious cash and a whole lot of mods to get it there.
So is it worth it? I don't know. The new Fat Bob is almost $20k with tax and title. Throw in $10k for exhaust and some other mods to make it less ugly and perform a little better and you're now around $30k. For crying out loud, you can buy a Diavel Diesel for less than that!
So I support Harley attempting to modernize 100 percent. I just wish they had done a better job of doing it.
Performance Harley ? I wish so too.
However, based on my reading on this forum, it seems to me that the majority of the past and current generations of HD riders will measure new HD bikes by the following two metrics:
1. Sound
2. Look
Performance will not matter if the above the new HD bikes fail the above two check marks.
So it's VERY hard for the MoCo to make any performance bike if the HD engineers have to constantly worry about and have to stick to metric #1.
Ducati also produces one of the finest engine sounds that can be heard on the 748s or 996s with the dry clutch. Unlike HD, Ducati pursues performance. So if Ducati's customers don't like the sound of the new bikes, too bad, but performance will be the ultimate goal. Ducati is done with V-Twin engine and is moving towards V4 engine.
Young generations will want performance bike AND variety. I wish HD offers sport bikes and dirt bikes as well. I think that's how HD will be able to attract young riders.
Went to look at the Fat Bob, but they didn't have one in yet. Going to take a few weeks or more in order to get the new ones in stock. One thing I did notice was the sea of used bikes out in front of the dealer. Man, that was once a pipe dream for all of us.
I keep saying it. No better time to buy a Harley.
PS - For all of the people who are complaining about change. They've been making the XL line for about 60 years plus. You want the old style if bike? They still make it. Compared to that, all them there new bikes are just that. The touring line hasn't changed all that drastically either.
Last edited by Stretchman; Aug 27, 2017 at 09:01 PM.
Would you have coitus with Rosie O if she still looked the same, but was an animal in bed?
Like the previous poster...if it don't move me visually, I don't care how good the ride or how fast the motor. And, I spend a helluva lot more time looking at & admiring my bike than 1% of it.
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders
Almost every hardcore Harley rider I know cut their teeth on High performance bikes. Nearly everyone rode the fastest Kawasaki or Yamaha or Honda in their day. Many own Ducatis or beemers today. Most concerns you label as hate are legitimate opinions and concerns. It hurts discussion to label everything you personally disagree with as hate. Seems to be a bleed over from political attitudes. Don't listen to a different point of view, label it hate speech so you can ignore it. But this ain't politics, so we will keep saying what we think. If you read the comments, instead of backing yourself into a corner, you might see that most Harley riders came to Harley because they have enough performance, but more to the point, they are fun to ride. My WeeStrom was a great bike, my FZ blinding fast. They handled great. But my Harley is more fun to ride. No one will argue with you that some other brands are ultra sophisticated. So what, that does not add to your ride in 99% of riding.
Now we agree that the new Harley's are expensive. Even too expensive for someone just starting out in life. Who expects a millennial to get a loan and buy a $30,000 bagger. Not Harley, not Polaris. It is the seasoned rider to can appreciate what a Harley has to offer. Most riders rode less expensive or used bikes for a decade or more before even being interested in looking at a Harley. Why do you think this is different now? Apartments, first homes, cars, girlfriends, marriage, all have priorities too. But you miss the mark as millennials are buying baggers. The Question this thread and others that we are trying to answer is what Polaris is trying to answer as well, are blacked out more metric looking bikes what will keep Harley healthy. Polaris already knows the valanced fenders were a short lived fad to grab some sales momentum. Now let's see it Polaris has staying power. We all hope that harley will. We all make our own decisions about new bikes with our own wallets. Simply discounting what you disagree with when people post here about what works for them will leave you with a majority of one. Everybody agrees Harley needs to change, to grow and the sales world is changing before our eyes. You may write people who do not like the new Heritage, or the new Fatboy off, but many of the people you think don't get it still ride and buy motorcycles. It is not hate to post a point of view, but it is narrow minded to dismiss it because you disagree.
Now the new Breakout, that's a whole new monster. Extremely sleek looking. Can't image what a bike that small with the M8 114 would be like. Would love to take that out on a test ride, but seeing as how I just bought a new Ultra last week, it's probably best not to tempt myself.














