how much difference? really
Cruiser
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 156
Likes: 0
Well I am 6'2" 350 lbs probably look like a grizzly on a unicycle. I ride an 09 883 c and it has plent of power for me. I like the cheaper insurance the bigger tank and 50 + mpg. I have been 90 on mine it did it with out a problem.
Road Master
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 846
Likes: 13
From: Out there!
In answer to the original question having own both Sportsters and Big Twins I'd say look at the Dyna. The Sportster suspension bottoms out too easily, larger and more comfort will pay off...
Thread Starter
|
Cruiser
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 109
Likes: 0
From: Tulsa, OK
j/k if you are riding the 883 with no problems then maybe i should just test drive each of them and go from there.....
also, where can i get info on the conversion, it may actually be cheaper to get an iron and do the conv on it and like everyone else is saying save money on insurance, etc.
thanks,
John
Outstanding HDF Member
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 2,543
Likes: 59
From: Chicagoland
I realize some people have tighter budgets than others, and I can respect that. But why buy something that doesn't fit, wishing the whole time you had the right thing? That's spending foolishly. He was asking for honest opinions, so I gave it to him. But I can understand you're trying to justify what you did, it's just not a realistic statement. Maybe he doesn't want a touring bike, I can also understand that. Maybe the right bike that fits, would be something more like a Dyna or a softtail. I'm just being subjective, offering a broader insight.
1.- Can you cruise at 90? No.
2.- Are you comfortable on an all day ride? No
3.- I pay $260 a year for my FLHX insurance. That works out to $1.40 a day... if you can't afford that, then sell your motorcycle.
4.- Bigger tank? Mine holds 6 gallons.
5.- Gas mileage? If you have to worry about that on a motorcycle, refer to response number 3
6.- If you could squeeze your big foot in a boot that was $5 cheaper and a half size smaller... would you spend the extra $5 to get the right size, or save the $5 and be uncomfortable? Go ahead and do it and try to convince us all that was the best choice.
Some people would argue with the wall.
Road Master
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 1,050
Likes: 1
From: MCALLEN ,TX
I knew someone would chime and swear to this.
I realize some people have tighter budgets than others, and I can respect that. But why buy something that doesn't fit, wishing the whole time you had the right thing? That's spending foolishly. He was asking for honest opinions, so I gave it to him. But I can understand you're trying to justify what you did, it's just not a realistic statement. Maybe he doesn't want a touring bike, I can also understand that. Maybe the right bike that fits, would be something more like a Dyna or a softtail. I'm just being subjective, offering a broader insight.
1.- Can you cruise at 90? No.
2.- Are you comfortable on an all day ride? No
3.- I pay $260 a year for my FLHX insurance. That works out to $1.40 a day... if you can't afford that, then sell your motorcycle.
4.- Bigger tank? Mine holds 6 gallons.
5.- Gas mileage? If you have to worry about that on a motorcycle, refer to response number 3
6.- If you could squeeze your big foot in a boot that was $5 cheaper and a half size smaller... would you spend the extra $5 to get the right size, or save the $5 and be uncomfortable? Go ahead and do it and try to convince us all that was the best choice.
Some people would argue with the wall.
I realize some people have tighter budgets than others, and I can respect that. But why buy something that doesn't fit, wishing the whole time you had the right thing? That's spending foolishly. He was asking for honest opinions, so I gave it to him. But I can understand you're trying to justify what you did, it's just not a realistic statement. Maybe he doesn't want a touring bike, I can also understand that. Maybe the right bike that fits, would be something more like a Dyna or a softtail. I'm just being subjective, offering a broader insight.
1.- Can you cruise at 90? No.
2.- Are you comfortable on an all day ride? No
3.- I pay $260 a year for my FLHX insurance. That works out to $1.40 a day... if you can't afford that, then sell your motorcycle.
4.- Bigger tank? Mine holds 6 gallons.
5.- Gas mileage? If you have to worry about that on a motorcycle, refer to response number 3
6.- If you could squeeze your big foot in a boot that was $5 cheaper and a half size smaller... would you spend the extra $5 to get the right size, or save the $5 and be uncomfortable? Go ahead and do it and try to convince us all that was the best choice.
Some people would argue with the wall.
6ft 270+
I'd still take my nightster over a geezer-glide or a softail any day of the week.
Thread Starter
|
Cruiser
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 109
Likes: 0
From: Tulsa, OK
i appreciate everyones input on this....unfortunately i am working on a budget here that is why i'm focusing on the Sportster models rather than a Dyna or Softtail.
i really like the idea of just getting the 48 and already having all the "stuff" done that i would prefer to have done to it, except maybe a larger tank. but i didn't know maybe if i were to get a iron and then ride it for a bit and then get the conv. for it. i'm the kinda guy that just likes to get what i want the first go round, but i also like saving money so if buying the Iron and doing the conv. (later on) would save a few grand then it may be worth it going that route, but if its only saving a bit then, to me, its worth having what i want the day i buy the bike.
-John
i really like the idea of just getting the 48 and already having all the "stuff" done that i would prefer to have done to it, except maybe a larger tank. but i didn't know maybe if i were to get a iron and then ride it for a bit and then get the conv. for it. i'm the kinda guy that just likes to get what i want the first go round, but i also like saving money so if buying the Iron and doing the conv. (later on) would save a few grand then it may be worth it going that route, but if its only saving a bit then, to me, its worth having what i want the day i buy the bike.
-John
Advanced
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 63
Likes: 0
From: San Diego CA
i appreciate everyones input on this....unfortunately i am working on a budget here that is why i'm focusing on the Sportster models rather than a Dyna or Softtail.
i really like the idea of just getting the 48 and already having all the "stuff" done that i would prefer to have done to it, except maybe a larger tank. but i didn't know maybe if i were to get a iron and then ride it for a bit and then get the conv. for it. i'm the kinda guy that just likes to get what i want the first go round, but i also like saving money so if buying the Iron and doing the conv. (later on) would save a few grand then it may be worth it going that route, but if its only saving a bit then, to me, its worth having what i want the day i buy the bike.
-John
i really like the idea of just getting the 48 and already having all the "stuff" done that i would prefer to have done to it, except maybe a larger tank. but i didn't know maybe if i were to get a iron and then ride it for a bit and then get the conv. for it. i'm the kinda guy that just likes to get what i want the first go round, but i also like saving money so if buying the Iron and doing the conv. (later on) would save a few grand then it may be worth it going that route, but if its only saving a bit then, to me, its worth having what i want the day i buy the bike.
-John
What it all boils down to is you can get the best deal on a bike that is in their shop today. I live in San Diego which is the biggest military town in the country. The shops here sell out of Irons and Nightsters all day long because all the young Marines and Navy guys are willing to pay whatever. I got lucky when a dealer out here had 3 48's sitting in his shop and I had the money to buy a bike that day. Once the bikes are on the floor they are costing dealers money and they have every incentive to make deals but if they have to order things for you or get them transfered from other shops they have you buy the nuts and will charge you top dollar.
Walk into your local shop and see what they have, see what fits you and be prepared to buy somthing that day but allso be prepared to walk away if the deal isn't right. Dealers HATE letting money walk out the door. If you have the money to do the deal now you will have an edge and might be able to get something you didn't expect you could afford.
HD Forum Stories
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders
10 Worst Harley-Davidson Motorcycles Ever
Pouria Savadkouei
Killer Custom's Jail Break Is The Breakout That Refused to Blend In
Verdad Gallardo
Crazy Bunderbike Build Looks Amazing, But Is It Impossible to Ride?
Verdad Gallardo
Harley-Davidson Reveals Super Cool Cafe Racer Concept
Verdad Gallardo
Engraved Rebellion: Inside Bundnerbike's Glam Rock II
Verdad Gallardo
10 Motorcycles You Should Never Buy
Joe Kucinski
10 Things Harley-Davidson Needs to Fix in 2026
Verdad Gallardo
Southpaw Super Glide: A Left-Hand-Drive 1979 Harley FXE Built to Fit the Rider
Verdad Gallardo
The Best and Worst Harley-Davidson Moves of 2025
Verdad Gallardo
Tourer
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 271
Likes: 0
I'm just gonna throw this out there... and I'm kinda surprised no one has had the ***** to say it yet. Buy a bigger bike and be happier
in the long run. Sporties are not that comfortable for guys your size. Just being realistic.
Now everbody else... go ahead and throw bottles at me for tellin it like it is, I can take it.
in the long run. Sporties are not that comfortable for guys your size. Just being realistic.
Now everbody else... go ahead and throw bottles at me for tellin it like it is, I can take it.
Road Master
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 1,050
Likes: 1
From: MCALLEN ,TX
just cuz wannaride may not be comfortable on a bike doesnt mean sh*t. its what you want. I had my choice of bikes (to en extent) and i chose the nightster. big twin guys will always talk smack
