Would you go on this ride????
Most of the time I end up telling them whats wrong.
For instance, a few years ago I had an old 1988 Sportster. I brought it to the dealership to get new tires put on. I told them to check out the ignition system because I would get a delay in starting when I pushed the start button. Sometimes I could even smell burnt wire.
They had the bike for a few days and put the tires on, they called me and told me the good news.. the bike needed a new battery!! Yippee I said.
The funny thing was that I just installed a new battery that I got from Walmart. I work in an electronics company so I checked the battery out and it was perfect.
Anyway... when I go to pickup the bike the mechanic that worked on it comes out and tells me its all set but there will still be a slight delay after I push the start button. He tells me that because my motor was a Johnson Engine Technology 1200 upgrade it has too much compression and if I want the starter to turn the motor faster I need to install pressure relief valves. He even tells me that he has an old Sportster that does the same thing and thats what he had to do. I tell him that although I am not a bike mechanic I did some research and in 1988 Harley had 2 different starters for Sportsters. 883 bikes got a lower torque starter. Around 1994 they switch to high torque for all the bikes. I told him that maybe its the starter. He told me that the starter was perfect and that its the motor.
I had new battery cables too btw...
After about 6 months of smelling burnt wire and having the feeling that one day the bike might not start I ordered a new Harley Davidson high torque starter. Basically, its the stock Buell starter. I installed it myself and my bike started instantly from that day until the day I sold it. This highly decorated, inked up Harley mechanic was completely wrong.
Same thing happened with an independent some years later with a 1989 Sportster. The mechanic told me that the carb needed to be rejetted and cleaned. I told him I completely rebuilt the carb and the jetting should be correct but... I assumed he knows more than me. I also told him that I checked the coil and it checked out ok. I get the bike back after a week and its exactly the same as when I dropped it off. Stuttering, sputtering and spitting through the carb. I drop it back off and they have it for another week. I show up on a Saturday before closing because they knew I needed the bike for Sunday and the mechanic is in the parking lot with the bike frantically trying to get it repaired. Turned out to be a loose coil wire nut. They wacked me for $440.00 between the new coil and the labor to clean my already spotless carb and rejet it with the same jets that were in it.
The reason I choose to ride old school Evo's is because I can usually figure out whats wrong myself. If I thought that a dealer or an independent could do it better than I could myself I would certainly have them check it out. I just don't think they are any good at working on the old bikes. I am sure there are plenty of mechanics who are.. but they are getting fewer and harder to find.







