Non-Biker Guy From Georgia
Well, other than a couple of years with a Honda 500 Four back in the mid-1970's, I have no experience either. So, I cannot be be terribly helpful myself directly. However, life experience tells me that I need to broaden his vision a little, so the following day I took him to our local Harley dealer for him to see and feel something different. BTW, when I first asked if he had looked at Harleys, he replied something to the effect "Dad, Harleys are for old dudes like you".
Long story longer, we go to the dealer and I introduce my son the the sales guy and give him the back story. I tell the sales guy to show my son something appropriate for a new rider and to make his best case for a Harley over a Japanese bike. He directs us to the Sportsters and had him sit on the different models they had on the floor. Clearly, if my son had a MC license, they would have let him test drive any of them.
Most interesting to me was that the sales guy spent more time getting me to sit on a variety of bikes than he did my son. I guess he assumed I had deeper pockets. I kept reminding him that I was not the one shopping, but he kept directing me to different bikes he thought I might like. I had a ball.
Before we left, he talked to us about the rider's class, he showed us the bikes they use for the classes, he introduced us to the owner of the dealership and other key people there. Suffice it to say, we were both impressed with the experience and my son no longer thinks that Harleys are only for old dudes like me. If he had the money today, I believe he would be riding a Nightser as soon as he could complete the riders course. And, if I wasn't afraid of killing or maiming myself on a bike, I would be riding a Fat Boy Lo.
Long introduction, but that is how I ended up here to do some research for my son. I want to make sure he makes a wise decision so I need to educate myself before I can help him. So, I've spent the past few days reading and learning and I wanted to say hello and thanks for sharing your wisdom and experience so freely with the green horns.
Great site and good people.
Look into your local community college system. They usually offer MSF-beginner rider class, for less than the H-D rider's edge.
What ever you, and your son decide... PLEASE do take the course.
There's no shame in buying a used metric bike for a first bike..... YES... the H-D will likely "retain value" better than a metric... but after 4-5 years the metric will level off, and your son can buy a bike, ride it a while, to discover his own personal likes and dislikes, and then buy the best bike, that suits HIS needs
Trending Topics
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders

Also as stated above, nothing wrong with picking up a metric. Or, he could rent a few different bikes and get a feel for them.
-Jim






