questioning what dealer told me
If it wasn't for the amount of heat that these bikes put out from the factory, I doubt there would've been this much of a discussion about tuners. I had an 02 EFI Heritage up to 2 years ago, and there was zero heat issues. The only heat came from the oil bath under the seat and it had to be hot!
SilverV
The changing of the A/C does make a difference. Search the forums. There is different CFM rating for the different systems. You might want to look at the Doughtery Power Pack, Ness Big Sucker, Heavy Breather, RSD..... A good tuner gives you the capabilities to change the characteristics of the EFI system. Not unlike changing jets or swapping the carb on your car. Your just doing it electronically.
Just makes sense. More air = more gas = more bang. Some of it has to do with location and temperature as well. I live in an location deemed high altitude (3000' above sea level). I'll never make the same power as someone on the coast. You may find 5 to 15 hp gains there. Not that much on a 350 hp car.... but dramatic on a 82 hp bike.
Also MOCO limits the butterfly opens through the ECM. 80% until 3000 rpm is achieved I believe?
It's all up to what you want to do with your scooter. Some are just fine with the IED's and that's all that matters. Some are never happy no matter what they do. Knowledege is power. The more you know how it works, the better judgment you can make on what you want to do.
All in all KAUFMANSM wanted to know if the dealer was blowing smoke..... he can take from this thread and deceide. No one is telling anyone what they have to do, but some of the statements are out in left field (IMHO).
There's waaaay more to it, but this is the basics to make you just about dangerious...lol
Heywood
Last edited by heywood727; Oct 20, 2009 at 02:56 PM.
If it wasn't for the amount of heat that these bikes put out from the factory, I doubt there would've been this much of a discussion about tuners. I had an 02 EFI Heritage up to 2 years ago, and there was zero heat issues. The only heat came from the oil bath under the seat and it had to be hot!
This is not the first time I have experienced this either.
I have slapped a pipe on air cooled single cylinder (4 stroke) dirt bikes with no other tuning and had no issues.(yes I know 2 strokes are a different story)
Don't get me wrong here....I am not denying the gains in HP or heat reduction that can be gained with proper tuning on any bike, but I suspect that it may be way more important on some bikes in some situations than others.
I also suspect that some manufactures and dealers take advantage of their customers when it comes to this issue and do more "tuning" than is really necessary.
Why MoCo can't make it run right in stock trim to the point where a stage 1 is almost mandatory is my real issue...and you cant blame it all on the EPA.
This is not the first time I have experienced this either.
I have slapped a pipe on air cooled single cylinder (4 stroke) dirt bikes with no other tuning and had no issues.(yes I know 2 strokes are a different story)
Don't get me wrong here....I am not denying the gains in HP or heat reduction that can be gained with proper tuning on any bike, but I suspect that it may be way more important on some bikes in some situations than others.
I also suspect that some manufactures and dealers take advantage of their customers when it comes to this issue and do more "tuning" than is really necessary.
Why MoCo can't make it run right in stock trim to the point where a stage 1 is almost mandatory is my real issue...and you cant blame it all on the EPA.
Outside of HD (excluding the V-Rod) I don't think there is anyone else that's not water cooled in this size of a bike?
A pair of cheap IED's are all the insurance most of us need to maintain safe AFR's for stock bikes or bikes with different pipes or AC's (although replacing the stock AC is as useful as attaching a propellor to your handle-bar, but that's another thread).
Last...please note that "closed-loop" is where we ride nearly 100% of the time. Tuners don't go there.
I'm no expert either. But you don't have to be an expert to use a bit of common sense. This thread is a perfect demonstration of why stealers do so well selling the un-needed to the un-knowing.
.
Last edited by Faast Ed; Oct 20, 2009 at 05:39 PM.
Outside of HD (excluding the V-Rod) I don't think there is anyone else that's not water cooled in this size of a bike?
The Royal Star and the V-Max are liquid cooled but they are V-4's.
Not sure I could be convinced that the size of the motor has that much to do with it.Yeah, I know the theory...bigger motor means more power, means more heat generated.
But test that theory by grabbing the pipe on a 650cc with your bare hands........
A pair of cheap IED's are all the insurance most of us need to maintain safe AFR's for stock bikes or bikes with different pipes or AC's (although replacing the stock AC is as useful as attaching a propellor to your handle-bar, but that's another thread).
Last...please note that "closed-loop" is where we ride nearly 100% of the time. Tuners don't go there.
I'm no expert either. But you don't have to be an expert to use a bit of common sense. This thread is a perfect demonstration of why stealers do so well selling the un-needed to the un-knowing.
That's a blanket statement, but for what it's worth, with the TTS You have a small ability to change a/f in close loop by increasing the milli volt number of closed loop bias map.
Yes I know that people do stage 1 upgrades with fuel management on other brands of bikes but it just does not seem to be mandatory the way it is with HD.
My wife's V Star has a set of V&H Shortshots on it and is otherwise stock with no tuning.
It's been that way for 4 years and 35k miles.
Starts easy, runs great...no popping, no smoke...nothing other than a slight bluing of the front head pipe.
Yes it's a carbed bike but even that has not been messed with, it's still at the factory settings.
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders
Lastly I was looking through the calibrations and didn't really find one for a '09 FXD with air filter & exhaust mods (stage 1). In fact even with the updated program version 1.005.0000, the latest bikes it shows calibrations for is 2008 models. The closest I found was for a 2007-08 "all market" with shotgun/shorty dual exhaust with O2 sensors #176AE105. The problem I have with this cal. is that it list 25 degree injectors. I read in another thread that these are "stock" injectors for the '08-'09 models. Is this true? If not, does anyone know which calibration will put me in the ballpark? I was also looking at #202TD002 which says it's for a 1580 with all parameters as stock but with "touring" exhaust. Just comparing the 2 calibrations, I see a lot of differences in the AFR settings. So if anybody knows what calibration I should start with I'd deeply appreciate any and all advise.
Thanks for a great forum and ride safe!







