You're welcome. Most riders I know like the heel toe deal.

 

Took mine off after getting my foot tangled up & almost dropping the bike...had the same problem with my ultra...more room for my size 13s

 

i have a size 15 foot so the heal shifter was removed before the bike went out the door at the dealership ... most useless part ever in my book ...

this is what you're looking for ...

35495-06 Heel/Toe Shifter Shaft Cover with Insert

Conceal the splined shifter shaft when you remove the heel shift lever. The kit includes a cover for the shaft end and an insert that conceals the casting and nylon spacer inboard of the shift lever. Manufactured from billet aluminum, these easy-to-install chrome plated covers are held in place with flush allen screws for a clean appearance.

Fits '00-later FL Softail® models equipped with Heel/Toe shift levers. Installation requires removal of heel shift lever.

MSRP US $26.95