If it was charged and tested good on the cold crank amperage test, what more can you ask. Mine is over 5 years old and still works. One I took out of truck was 7. At that age you need to test it ever season however. No big deal. You could get a new one, and it could fail in 3 months.

 

It was worth it to me for the peace of mind to spend the $90.00 once they told me it was six years old. My only question was if the HD code B7 on the battery means it was made in February of 2007.