Farout reaching headlight.
http://www.harley-davidson.com/store...11-67700189--1
I'm sorry about your injuries and the damage to your bike. Think positive; it could have been much worse and it is approaching winter so you won't be riding much anyway. You now have time to recover.
As you've seen from the others responses, it will come down to HID vs LED. I would disregard any argument about which one is brighter because there is support for both sides. You'll have to choose for yourself. There is no question that HID is less expensive than LED. If you choose LED, Truck-Lite is less expensive than HD. Yes, I know, everything is less expensive than HD. The HD LED Reflector headlamp is new [HD part 67700189]. This is the first year it has been out so I cannot offer you any comparison to the HD Daymaker LED headlamp [HD part 73391-10A].
Do what you normally do and purchase what is best for you. If you are concerned about rocks getting kicked up and taking out your headlight than you might as well put the stock incandescent back in.
For the greatest visibility, I would remount the passing lamps. That will mean you have to remove your Ness chrome cowbells or modify the passing lamp bracket. I would also install what Redbeard mentioned; the Independent Control Auxiliary Lamp wire harness kit [HD part 69200442]. It is a $30 wire harness that allows your passing lamps to remain on with the high beam. It will maximize peripheral illumination at night.
Personally, I chose the HD LED Daymaker and LED passing lamps.

Get well brother.
http://bogiesreviews.webs.com/Review...ng%20Lamps.pdf
Might help in your decision.











