SERT v. Power Commander
Trending Topics
I think it safe to say that most here including me have purchased the PCIII and/or PCV from Fuel Moto, and IMO this is the best bang-for-the-buck option available. Do a search on them and read the positive reviews, as their forte is providing excellent maps matched to your bike and hardware, and to me that is a big deal-maker. The PCV will allow switching between two maps, has a very good feature set that will fit most riders, and can be upgraded to Auto-Tune if desired. Fuel Moto maps are accurate, and any statements that a map created on another bike is not right for yours is simply not true. The map-switch option to me is a big winner for the PCV. You can create one map for gas mileage (lean in the cruise-range) without sacrificing performance as the throttle-position increases, and another set richer in the cruise range for extra cooling when needed. Basically you can have mileage and cooling at the flip of a switch and performance either way. I did a write-up here on setting-up Auto-Tune for this purpose. Another deal-maker for Fuel Moto is their excellent customer service.
Regarding the benefit and accuracy of canned maps, the same goes for the flash-based tuners, but for them these maps are few and far-between. Latus HD and perhaps other do have some maps for these which you can purchase.
The flash-based options are powerful tools that allow you to access the ECM in ways you can't with the PCV, but unless you can find a good canned map will require a dyno-tune to properly tune the open-loop areas. Statements that this isn't required are simply not true because there is no feedback in open-loop mode (above ~50% throttle) with the stock hardware.
Thundermax replaces the ECM entirely and like the PCV AT provides auto-tune capability using Bosch LSU4 wide-band O2 sensors, and Fuel Moto also sells these. IMO the downside to T'Max is that the bike's on-board MAP and knock sensors are disabled, and it is very pricey. The flash-based tuners as well as the PCV all retain functionality of the bike's on-board sensors.
I think it's safe to say that most of the features offered by any of these tuners will not be of use to most riders, as most just want control of AFR's and ignition timing for better cooling and performance. You'll get that with any of these options, and even some of the lower-priced tuners may get you the fundamentals at the expense of less flexibility.
Also, Certified Drunk made a very good point: If you are set on doing a dyno-tune, buy the tuner that person prefers to use.
Last edited by iclick; Aug 22, 2010 at 10:35 AM.
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders










