Bagger wobble exposed!
The alloy art brackets do seem far less robust, but if they do the job I can't see how that'll make a difference. And if, as previously stated, Eric Buell came up with the design, then all these vendors are just copying the concept if not the specifics.
I just ordered the alloy art product and will report back once I have a chance to really get out and ride and see if I can tell a difference, which unfortunately is likely to be several months out. If it doesn't seem to work for me I will attempt to hatchet job something together myself--not like any super precise engineering is required. I'm afraid opening a box with two brackets and a turnbuckle for which I paid $400 is likely to give me an acute case of buyers' remorse regardless of the result, but results may vary for the rest of you doctors and lawyers.
When I added Pro-Action shocks to our last bike a 2016 Limited I could not believe the difference in handling. It was rock solid in corners.
Yes I know there are many other factors but the really crappy stock suspension magnifies these problems.
Just my opinion.
The alloy art brackets do seem far less robust, but if they do the job I can't see how that'll make a difference. And if, as previously stated, Eric Buell came up with the design, then all these vendors are just copying the concept if not the specifics.
I just ordered the alloy art product and will report back once I have a chance to really get out and ride and see if I can tell a difference, which unfortunately is likely to be several months out. If it doesn't seem to work for me I will attempt to hatchet job something together myself--not like any super precise engineering is required. I'm afraid opening a box with two brackets and a turnbuckle for which I paid $400 is likely to give me an acute case of buyers' remorse regardless of the result, but results may vary for the rest of you doctors and lawyers.
Oh, a good shock can help both front and rear. You can get a pogo action that will make the bike dance. Even the best stiffener won't work without good shocks.
Last edited by Max Headflow; Jan 6, 2018 at 12:18 PM. Reason: won't
The interesting thing about this thread (IMO) is that it focuses on that movement and how to stop it. All seem to agree that a good brace will stop it. Also seems that changing (renewing those beyond useful life or “upgrading”) the bushings/mounts along with proper set up is a cure. Me thinks doing both makes sense but is only me and is not cheap.
As none of us can buy examples of each solution and compare empirically how they contribute we are stuck with the few press reviews or feedback from happy owners in forums. It seems that thorough google searching provides not one thread that says “I bought product x and it made my bike wobble”. There are some reports about increased vibration from non OEM mounts and pivot bushings but most seem to have been been cured with proper setup.
Reading the last posts I have a question: It looks like the Alloy Art product is available only for 2009 and later bikes and Tru Track has a solution for all rubber mounted models. It does look as if the Alloy Art mounted the way it does to the starter motor mounts and frame will do an OK job of allowing up and down but not side to side movement. This assumes the bolt into the frame and the material it is made from are sufficiently robust (starter motor mount must be stronger and safer than the transmission cover bolting method of the TT)
Opinions?
The interesting thing about this thread (IMO) is that it focuses on that movement and how to stop it. All seem to agree that a good brace will stop it. Also seems that changing (renewing those beyond useful life or upgrading) the bushings/mounts along with proper set up is a cure. Me thinks doing both makes sense but is only me and is not cheap.
As none of us can buy examples of each solution and compare empirically how they contribute we are stuck with the few press reviews or feedback from happy owners in forums. It seems that thorough google searching provides not one thread that says I bought product x and it made my bike wobble. There are some reports about increased vibration from non OEM mounts and pivot bushings but most seem to have been been cured with proper setup.
Reading the last posts I have a question: It looks like the Alloy Art product is available only for 2009 and later bikes and Tru Track has a solution for all rubber mounted models. It does look as if the Alloy Art mounted the way it does to the starter motor mounts and frame will do an OK job of allowing up and down but not side to side movement. This assumes the bolt into the frame and the material it is made from are sufficiently robust (starter motor mount must be stronger and safer than the transmission cover bolting method of the TT)
Opinions?
https://www.alloyart.com/bagger/txr-...-baker-oil-pan
Their product that mounts above the transmission, not below is the one I referred to, it is very different to the TT and the way it works
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders
I suspect tire wear may be a factor given poor road surfaces seem to exacerbate the issue more of late.
Seems to me that with the exception of the smooth rider these stabilizer products all function in fundamentally the same fashion with turnbuckle/pivots arranged to try and limit lateral motion. I am concerned about vibration as well, but sounds like that issue has cropped up for all...












