The Everything 2018+ Heritage Thread
So, I picked up a set of V&H Twin Slash mufflers from my local dealer.
I rode the Rineharts and V&H mufflers within 1 hour of each other. Here are my thoughts on both:
Rinehart
+ Very loud. (Although it gets a bit tiresome on long rides, and I wear earplugs!)
+ Nice-looking end caps. (They do get a rust color inside them though.)
+ Very large diameter so they look "beefy".
+ Great "fat" tone.
+ Uses gaskets so very easy to remove and reinstall.
- Very expensive. ($500)
- No instructions. (Although, if you need instructions you probably shouldn't be installing them!)
- No gaskets. ($12 each.)
- No clamps. ($7 each.)
- No heat shield. (The junction between the mufflers and the header shield looks a bit unfinished.)
V&H Twin Slash
+ Inexpensive ($350)
+ Not very loud. (IMO, almost perfect.)
+ Heat shields. (The junction between the mufflers and the header shield looks great.)
+ Includes clamps.
+ Decent instructions.
- No gaskets used, so possibly not-so-easy to remove and reinstall.
- Very weak-looking clamps. (They work though. Dunno if they can be reused.)
- Not very loud.
My riding impressions are that the Rineharts sound totally awesome but over 6-8 or more hours the sound begins to wear on me. The V&H have a less-deep tone but sound like "classic" V&H pipes. The Rineharts have a "fat" or "smoothed" sound whereas the V&H is more distinct and crisp. The V&H sound better under hard acceleration but the Rineharts sound better at idle. At cruise, the V&H are barely audible. The Rineharts are always loud. The Rinehart lower muffler rubs the muffler bracket a bit which isn't a big deal but it does leave marks on the bracket and muffler. You can't see them, though. My butt dyno is not calibrated very well but the V&H feel like they hold 55MPH in sixth gear (2090RPM) better, so perhaps they have a bit more low-end torque. I think if you put the quiet inserts into the V&H pipes you would have a very quiet pipe. I don't know how loud the V&H "competition" inserts are but at $50 each I don't plan to find out.
Summary: The V&H are a great value for a medium-loud pipe. The Rineharts sound great if you like loud pipes but they are expensive.
Last edited by Yzzyx; Oct 29, 2018 at 08:38 AM.
The Best of Harley-Davidson for Lifelong Riders
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLXX6XVAeOs
Here's a pic of mine. Still fairly stock aside from the Stage 2.

Last edited by escalade6103; Oct 29, 2018 at 09:05 PM.
I've changed it a few times since then, but it was just a bronze colored HD bar and shield logo. Think it was $5 at the dealer.







